RANDOM JOTTINGS


A blog about music, sports, theatre and rants





Just to confirm that this is a Rant so ignore if you wish.

I have been reading Good Housekeeping for years.  Its title is really anachronistic these days but it would be difficult to change the title, much though the editorial team might like to, as it is such a well known brand.  It has changed and moved on with the times but I have to say that over the last year or so I have begun to find it rather irritating.

The latest edition really got me cross. First of all, the woman on the cover was Fiona Bruce. Now this is purely a personal thing – many of my regular readers know that this woman drives me mad. The BBC use her for anything they can lay their hands on – a few years back she did a series of historical progs on the Beeb, none of which she was qualified for, and she is the perennial host on Antiques Roadshow and now, gawd help us, she fronts Question Time. She also pops up on the news. It seems she is multi talented….

But as I said this is a personal thing and merely started me off feeling twitchy. So I read on. The usual reader's letters, beauty products, suggested gifts for Christmas, nothing to get worked up about all pretty inoffensive.

Then we come to the Trail Blazers. Woman who have Made their Mark. Well what is wrong with this Elaine I hear you cry? Well, nothing at all. Merely that I am getting fed up with reading about them.  We have the Managing Director of Penguin, then a Doctor of science Womanwho wants to make science more accessible to girls and women, then the female CEO of Citroen. Nothing wrong with this at all. All high powered, all guaranteed to make the rest of us feel totally inadequate.

Further on we come across Women who have all had to Reinvent themselves for various reasons.  One woman raised a family then decided to become a student and take a degree in social work (most of these woman seem to manage the financial side of it all – perhaps having a husband working helps). Another was a high flyer in corporate life who got sick of it all and gave it up when her child was ill – very good and understandable reason (she makes it clear that her husband was able to support them). So she spots an market opportunity and starts making 'bees wax wraps'. Don't ask. Needless to say she is successful and now works harder than she did in her earlier marketing job. Rather defeats the object methinks. Another woman was deserted by her husband but she picked herself up, started a web site marketing housekeeping, cleaning etc and then branched into catering and cooks meals for parties etc.

So what is wrong with all of this? well nothing but honestly I am getting So Tired of Inspirational Woman full of Empowerment.  One month we had women off climbing up Mount Kilimanjaro or swimming the Zambesi or deep sea diving or setting up a charity in the middle of the Sahara (ok I made that last one up but you get my drift).

I am sure all the magazine wants to do is inspire us.  Well some of us do not want to be inspired. We have enough to do already with working, raising a family, holding down a job (which is probably boring and repetitive but has to be done) without reading about these Superwoman who, incidentally, have obviously been made up to look totally glam for the magazine photoshoot. Do we ever see a woman who is knackered and shattered who has been up all night with a baby or exhausted from the commute home?

OK I am on a roll.

I come to an article on the MENOPAUSE. Another one full of all the suffering and angst this can cause.  I DON'T WANT TO KNOW. I AM NOT INTERESTED.

Flick over the page. An article on a mother coping with her son who wants to be a woman. Then an article on how to overhaul your life and beome creative and transform your health and improve your mental wellbeing.   By now I am feeling exhausted.

Now I come to the finance pages. How to be MINDFUL of your money. Yes Mindful. I read on and find that if you take a mindful attitude you will feel happier and less stressed and we must identify our bad habits – seems many of us have unhelpful beliefs about money relating to our childhood – there I knew my mum making me put pennies in my money box would come back to haunt me.

So we have a guide to Managing Money Mindfully. I have to practice money visualisation. We have to concentrate on making our debt get smaller. Apparently our brain then gets the message that this must be done. Note: only money visualisation I do is to plan how to spend it when I win the Lottery.  Every month we have to have a Money Cleanse. No not money laundering but a Cleanse. After reading this section what it boils down to is checking your bank balance…..

Bear with me gentle readers, I am nearly finished. 

The back page of this mag always has a "Celebrity" asking questions about their life and making us all feel a bit pig sick.  It bears no relation to real life at all. Imagine asking Benedict Cumberbatch when he puts the bins out – that sort of thing.

This time it was an Actress, I refuse to call her an actor and she tells us that she would rather not cook for friends but eat out (wouldn't we all deary?) Asked what food she could not live without she anwers, perfectly reasonably, chocolate. But not a Yorkie or a bar of Dairy MIlk is good enough. No it has to be "good dark chocolate, preferably a single origin bean" A Single Origin Bean??

Of course her kitchen cupborad must-haves are cloves, garlic, chamomile and spearmint tea, almond milk, sea salt and blackpepper, chickpeas and tasty bread.  (Mine are tinned tomatoes, pasta and baked beans just for the record)

And then the final touch that made me throw the magazine across the room.  Apparently she is now into "simple, fresh vegetarian food" and do you know what her signature dish is – this fresh simple food?  Roasted beetroot and baked feta cooked with lemon thyme, served with blood oranges and chickpeas in a rich shallot and fresh flat leaf parsley and mint herb dressing.

FFS. No I am not going to just leave the initials. For fuck's sake.

This magazine is for women.  And most women just get on with it. We don't do mavellous inspiring things. We live our lives. We raise our children. We hold down jobs. We cook, yes we do. We also clean. We shop. We look after our families, aged parents. Now I left a marriage when I was 52. I had to remake my life, my social life and deal with the fall out I had created by my departure. It was hard it was miserable but I bloody well got on with it. I do not think I have done a wonderful thing. I do not think I am inspirational. I just wake up each morning and do what has to be done. I have not gone walking along the Great Wall of China for charity, I have not scaled Mount Everest. I have not written a novel nor have I started an online business. I just live my life like millions of ordinary women.

Now I appreciate this is a personal rant and many of you may love reading about Woman who are Empowered etc etc and that is fine, but I honestly feel when reading articles like this that it can make you feel that you have achieved very little in life and become dissatisfied. It does not affect me this way, as you will have gathered by now if you have read this far. I just get pissed off with it all.

So tonight I will be sitting eating my ready meal from a well known chain store, in my nightie, watching Strictly Come Dancing and feeling perfectly content with my lot.

I sometimes long for the days of Women's magazines when you got a few short stories, a serial, a few recipes and a knitting pattern….

Posted in

61 responses to “Random Rant – Empowerment, mindfulness and all that Jazz”

  1. Joan (Devon) Avatar
    Joan (Devon)

    I think Princess Anne is the best of the bunch!

  2. , Erika W. Avatar
    , Erika W.

    Tina:
    The Lady was the last magazine I read with enjoyment. My now deceased first mother-in-law sent it out to me from England. I passed it on to a couple of friends in the US here and we all agreed that it was still worth reading unlike any of the awful American women’s ones which are 90% advertisements and the rest just nonsense.

  3. , Erika W. Avatar
    , Erika W.

    I remember how a group of us would dash out to buy Woman and Woman’s Own as soon as they were available. We four were undergraduates at Newnham College, Cambridge. The buyer got to read them first. When it was me I would retire to one of the college bath tubs and read at leisure–with the odd top-up of boiling hot water.

  4. Jean Avatar
    Jean

    Elaine,
    Thank you! I agree with you 100%. I have slowly stopped reading these magazines and no longer subscribe the way I used to.
    Jean

  5. Elaine Avatar

    I am pretty sure our library has this service. Also I get magazines through my membership of Amazon Prime and can take my pick so really my magazine expenditure is now practically nil

  6. Veronica Banting Avatar
    Veronica Banting

    Can I suggest people who like browsing magazines for free check out if their library service has Press Reader a great online newspaper and magazine service. You can just read the bits you are interested in and ignore the rubbish. I always check out the women’s mags for book reviews. You can download them on to an iPad and read anywhere.

  7. Elaine Avatar

    Ah but you have to be “mindful” now

  8. Elaine Avatar

    I have rather clung to it as I have taken it for so long but of course we can change and then a magazine no longer suits us. I used to be a Cosmopolitan girl but that was a long time ago!

  9. Elaine Avatar

    I shall not be renewing my subscription. If I want to be preached to I will go to church,

  10. Elaine Avatar

    I doubt you are boring Sue

  11. Elaine Avatar

    I do find Megan irritating but I also get the feeling she is totally bewildered by it all and not sure what to do. Listen to advice would be a good thing

  12. Elaine Avatar

    Precisely!

  13. Hilary Avatar
    Hilary

    Great stuff Elaine, totally agree with you about womens’ magazines.
    The thing that annoys me is fashion articles about “how to wear…”- just put it on!

  14. tina Avatar
    tina

    I so agree Elaine, in fact I gave up on GH a few years ago – rather tired of it making me feel inadequate and actually, not interested in Slebs or the ghastly fashion. Actually I like the Lady – interesting articles, good crossword – rather a lot about care homes etc but doesn’t bang on about transforming your life. I agree totally with the comments on Country Living too.
    Glad I’m not the only one and not surprising these magazines are struggling.

  15. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    Exhausting.I get that being fabulously rich and having an adoring husband like harry and nothing to do but worry about your image would take it out of a woman but still feel Meghan needs a brief chat with Princess Anne:)

  16. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    It’s also pernicious, encouraging some people to feel they’d definitely be better off employing a man and sadly some women to feel real dread of what they have been led to believe is the inevitable horror awaiting them. I know I was lucky. Having an easy menopause is not the result of self-discipline or strength of character. BUT women need to know it can and does happen.

  17. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    I laughed like the proverbial drain reading this. Thank you!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  18. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    Sorry, I find you entirely inspirational! feel much the same way about friend-up-the-road who has been quietly fostering troubled teenage girls for years, ever since her husband died in the middle of arranging to foster the first one. Never seen her or anyone like her in a magazine. Funny that.

  19. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    Well, I’m glad that you did. I’m entirely hypocritical about lots of things which is why I don’t go round preaching to other people but there are far too many people in the public eye who have shall we say very elastic consciences when it comes to their own actions but very firm views on other peoples.

  20. Lizzie Avatar
    Lizzie

    Usually a bit of a blog lurker, I feel compelled to comment.
    Elaine, your post has made me laugh, along with striking home so aptly with your rant.
    I have a long standing subscription to GH, and have felt for a long time that it no longer hits the spot or meets my particular needs as a reader.
    I have been too lazy to cancel, but certainly will now, for all the reasons you do eloquently quote.
    Thanks for the push I needed. There are now so many mags on the market, but none matching the likes of Nova, for example. If only…..

  21. Sue Cuthbert Avatar
    Sue Cuthbert

    Phew – I’m exhausted reading all the comments back and forth.
    And just grateful that I’ve not read or bought a glossy mag since 1979! Not reading has made me the person I am – boring, without make up and expensive clothes or a high flying business – but contented with my life, home and family and with more money in the bank!!

  22. Elaine Simpson-Long Avatar
    Elaine Simpson-Long

    I am currently responding to all these great comments propped up in bed with a cup of tea. I have book reviews to do today, I have filing to do and also will be going online for Christmas presents (I do this in tranches over three months), I will be making soup for lunch and then I have a jigsaw on the go. Hardly an inspirational day, but I shall enjoy. I have been rushing around all week on grandchildren duty and will be again next week so these days of quiet are essential for me.
    Not inspiring but nice

  23. Elaine Simpson-Long Avatar
    Elaine Simpson-Long

    I used to love glossy mags but over the last few years have bee buying less and less which is probably better for my pocket as they are now so expensive, You could buy a book for the price of some of them. No need to confess to anything, I am not sitting in judgement!

  24. Elaine Simpson-Long Avatar
    Elaine Simpson-Long

    Bore on Erika. I do!
    I used to read Woman and Woman’s Own as my mother took them and, yes ok by todays standards they are very much slanted towards the “little woman’, but there was good reading there and yes great knitting patterns. I knitted my ex an Aran sweater from one of these mags and over 40 years later he is still wearing it.
    We are now living in the Mindful Woke era and gosh it is tiring

  25. Elaine Simpson-Long Avatar
    Elaine Simpson-Long

    I do my shopping online through a catalogue these days as trudging around shops trying to get good fitting clothes is so difficult now. I used to be an M&S lady but finding stuff that fits me there is now a thing of the past. I put on weight, which I am now shedding, but am never going to be stick thin. I don’t bother with sales as the larger sizes are all gone which should tell the stores something but no it doesn’t.
    May I recommend Bravissimo for bras? I have been going to them for years and, as a GG, I feel your pain. I don’t know where you are located but they have plenty of stores and, natch, are online. Their customer service is excellent and the staff soo friendly and helpful. And the staff who work there are all well endowed and know how you feel

  26. Elaine Simpson-Long Avatar
    Elaine Simpson-Long

    And I mean it. Keep in touch. Where in Cambs are you? Not being nosy but my family have just moved to Cambridge

  27. Elaine Simpson-Long Avatar
    Elaine Simpson-Long

    Well Joan you obviously felt strongly about it. Your reason for disliking her is at least a valid one. I just find her acutely irritating and smug which is totally irrational

  28. Joan (Devon) Avatar
    Joan (Devon)

    Hardly scandulous, I know, but to me it was about principles. Wish I hadn’t mentioned it.

  29. Gillie Avatar
    Gillie

    Used to love GH thirty years ago before I left for foreign shores. What a shame, not something I would buy now, reading your rant. Oh well,,off to continue my life of quiet desperation which is pretty good really!

  30. Ann Avatar
    Ann

    I do love your rants and agree with you entirely – though I haven’t actually bought a magazine for years I do see them at the dentist’s etc. I have a confession to make though – I do like Fake or Fortune as I am interested in art and enjoy the expertise of Philip Mould.

  31. Erika W. Avatar
    Erika W.

    Yes, yes and yes again.
    Many years ago, in the 1950s, magazines, whether for women in particular or not , were written for intelligent people. Dare I say written BY intelligent people also?
    Who else here is old enough to remember “Housewife”, “Lilliput” and “Everybody’s”? These three were a delight., read by every generation in my family, from us youngsters to my grandparents–and the males of the family also.
    Then, of course, there was “The Listerner”, which was more sophisticated…I could remember more but don’t want to be a bore.

  32. Kate of Cambs Avatar
    Kate of Cambs

    I appreciate that very much Elaine – thank you xx

  33. Elaine Avatar

    I think Gh is trying too hard now and it shows. They also changed editors a year or so ago and that is when I noticed the difference. I have given up on so many other mags. I used to like the Home type magazines but again found they were peopled by couples doing up homes who were called St John and Veronica who bought a run down barn and did it up and you can now rent it on Air BNB. Just pretentious rubbish and so far removed from ordinary life and ordinary folk that it makes one cringe. So all of those were binned. I used to like Home and Antiques but it changed its format a couple of years ago and I have found it to be too pretentious. So perhaps you are right and I should give ALL magazines up!
    I am SO fed up with hearing about the menopause I really am. If another Sleb appears on tv or in a mag saying how traumatic it was I shall scream.

  34. Michelle Ann Avatar
    Michelle Ann

    I agree with all you say, but my particular bugbear is the fashion articles. Most of the time they assume their reader is an 18-ish, size 8, millionaire’s daughter, when most of their readers are 60-ish, size 16-ish ladies with a limited budget. When they do deign to show fashion for the ‘older woman’, it is always on a size 8 woman who has had plastic surgery, but with grey hair just to show she’s ‘elderly’. For the millions of us who are not stock size, I want to know where I can find jackets that are not too short, and that fit a 36 DD bust (Marks and Spencer’s most popular bra size) without having massive shoulders. I also want to know where I can find narrow fitting shoes, and a bra with straps that don’t slide off my shoulders, but I feel I will wait a very long time for useful articles like these.

  35. Margaret Powling Avatar

    I thought the rant was going to be about Strictly and then what you wrote was even better!!! Having written for magazines I know how hard for them to come up with something different every month but each magazine has its target readership and as well as that is very product led (i.e. to survive they have to sell advertising space and then they have to link the articles to those adverts; they are also linked to the seasons so right now it’s all hot soups and woolly jumpers and Christmas is mentioned from the October issue onwards, which comes out in September). I never had a commission from Good Housekeeping even though I pitched ideas occasionally, but really, I gave up on GH when I was in my late 30s.
    I’ve always loved monthly glossies but I only like the house magazines such as The English Home, House & Garden, Homes & Antiques and Period Living (and for a year I’ve had a subscription to The World of Interiors, too, just to be greedy for my magazine fix). So, Elaine, my advice dear soul is to find another magazine. You have outgrown GH, and did so a long time ago I think. Read it, if you must, in the hair dresser’s. As for Miss Bruce, oh dear, where does one begin … not only reading the News, presenting Antiques Roadshow and Question Time, there’s also Fake or Fortune with Philip Mould. As for the menopause … we women all go through at at one time or another, its not unusual nor is it news. Get over it I say (to magazines, I mean).
    Just loved your rant and agreed with every word, Elaine.

  36. Elaine Avatar

    OK well this rant has certainly triggered off a lot of response both here and on FB and twitter which I was not expecting. I must emphasise that this is a personal rant and I fully expect to be disagreed with and some have. I just feel too much pressure is put on women to be all dancing all singing and high achievers.
    I believe it was Shirley Conran who said we can have it all (correct me if I am wrong I probably am) but I do not think we can. Something has got to give.
    And I did watch Strictly tonight in my nightie and dressing gown and had a great evening!!
    Keep the responses coming I am loving them
    x

  37. Elaine Avatar

    Oh Debbie this made me laugh!! The amount of businesses that started with a moment of inspiration at a kitchen table! I ran my own business, a small catering company, when my children were small and looking back at it all when I was doing it, bringing up children, chairman of a music festival etc et I wonder how I did it. I now feel that I could easily feature in one of these mags because of this.
    16 orgasms – yes well….
    and have you noticed when a high flyer goes and lived in the country she manages to renovate a house and let it out or make home made chutney or jam or weave baskets and knit things? It drives me MAD. Never any mention of mucking out the pigs

  38. Elaine Avatar

    Now if I said you were inspirational you would probably tell me to bog off but you are a prime example of what I mean. Just getting on with it. YOu have my admiration and please do keep in touch on the blog or email me if you wish
    Good luck to you and keep strong xx

  39. Elaine Avatar

    I think I have started something as I have had some responses on twitter ad FB. Not all agreeing with me by a long stretch but a lot do. I have made it clear that this is a personal view and I know others will disagree

  40. Elaine Avatar

    Ah I see

  41. Elaine Avatar

    Fiona – do tell!
    I just feel the relentless pressure after reading this month’s edition. Perhaps it was a particularly heavy one I don’t know but by the time I got to the Sleb on the back page poncing on about her ‘simple food’ I was at screaming pitch.
    Yes I rather yearn for the old days of knitting patterns…

  42. Elaine Avatar

    I feel so many women are unsung heroes. They are not on tv, they are not in the press, they do not do things that catch the eye, they just get on with it. All these women featured are great, but I have just had enough of reading about them quite frankly.
    Meghan – ah well. In a way I feel for her. I said when she got engaged to Harry that she was going to find it difficult. Kate did the same when she married William. And of course, being American and living the Hollywood life did not prepare her for what she has faced. When you are a Hollywood star you live in a bubble and only hear good things so I imagine it has all been a shock for her. Part of me feels sorry for her, part of my finds her profoundly irritating.

  43. Elaine Avatar

    Thankyou!!

  44. Joan (Devon) Avatar
    Joan (Devon)

    Helen, most people wouldn’t have noticed or be bothered about it, but it angered me then and still does if I catch a glimpse of her. First let me say that I am quite observant and notice things about people which includes what they are wearing, accessories etc. For a long time, if not years Ms Bruce wore a small crucifix around her neck. Years ago, I don’t know if you remember it, there was an ongoing news story when an airport employee was sacked because she wore a crucifix and refused to take it off when there was a complaint by a customer, who was offended by the crucifix. The story went on for days and caused a lot of comments as you can imagine. During this news story Ms Bruce appeared on the news minus the crucifix and as far as I know hasn’t worn it since. Was she kow-towing to the BBC bosses, who knows, but I lost all respect for her and stopped watching Antiques Roadshow when she started to appear in it even though I liked the programme. And no, I am not particularly religious.

  45. Debbie Avatar
    Debbie

    I gave up on magazines years ago.
    I got fed up with GH as you have done. Particularly the vibe where it was assumed you wanted a high-flying job, 6 children, a town place and a country place (for weekends), holidays in the sun and 16 orgasms a night (I wish).
    But the one that really got my goat was Country Living. I’d loved it from day 1 – but when the current editor took over it really went downhill. Two things did for me: 1. EVERY SINGLE ARTICLE was trying to sell me something – household goods,cosmetics, things the woman made herself in her bijou business (also see number 2) and sometimes even the bloody house featured! Now they have furniture, carpets and even hotels. 2. Every woman can start a kitchen-table business. Why? And what junk is being launched into the world on a whim? Little felty things for the Christmas Tree? Little sachets for any occasion stuffed with home dried herbs and finished with a pretty-ribbon woven by virgins in some other country? Strewth!
    And don’t get me started on the media’s discovery of the menopause……….

  46. Kate of Cambs Avatar
    Kate of Cambs

    A lot of that struck a chord with me too. I’m 54 and have being living with cancer for over four years. If I can continue to do my (low-paid, low-level) part-time admin jobs, keep the house even passably tidy, cook proper meals occasionally, get to church, and see my friends – then I’m reasonably happy. Some weeks not all of those things happen, and that’s fine, because mostly they do. And that takes up all the energy I have. As you say Elaine – just getting on with it. I’m not interested in celebrities and I don’t find most of those high-achieving women inspirational. Perhaps weirdly, I sometimes think I’d feel less patronised by recipes and knitting patterns.

  47. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    ‘I have a long memory’…do tell!!!!!!!!!!! Like you, I haven’t bought a woman’s magazine in years although younger friend gives them to me occasionally so have an idea what they’re like. Time was, you had the nutjobbers (all that ‘my husband ate my sister’s gerbil and regurgitated it for breakfast’ stuff) and then there were the decent ones. I remember when Women’s Journal had excellent new fiction, for example, and you could forgive them the horoscopes, but now………..!!!
    Think Elaine might have started something here! Funny thing is, there’s nothing out there for the 55+ market and yet we’re the ones with the spare cash. Well, SOME spare cash anyway!

  48. Joan (Devon) Avatar
    Joan (Devon)

    I agree with your rant, all of it, and that is why I don’t buy these glossy women’s magazines as there isn’t anything of interest to me. In fact I don’t buy any magazines, not since (going back years) Woman, Woman’s Own and Woman’s Weekly changed. They used to be the magazines you mention with short stories, cookery, decent knitting patterns and short interesting articles. It seems that most magazines these days all follow the same path with celebrity, celebrity, celebrity, which I am not interested in. Majority of them I’ve never heard of. I also agree with you about Fiona Bruce, can’t stand and don’t watch the woman and there is a reason for this. I have a long memory.

  49. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    Oh God, Elaine, I agree with every word!!! (esp about Saint Fiona). I’m also sick to death of reading about women and tragedy. Stuff happens. My sister committed suicide when I was six months from university finals. It was dreadful but you know what? I was still better off than she was.
    Menopause? o.k. I sailed through mine but even if I hadn’t I would never have expected my employer to give me time off for it because if I had it would have meant she’d probably never employ a 50 year old woman again.
    Teenage mental health issues? my heart bleeds for truly troubled teens (see above) but most of them just need something to do (I recommend dusting) and gentle encouragement to stop navel-gazing.
    Empowered women? funny how few of them are actually the sole breadwinner.
    And don’t get me started on bloody Meghan-of-the-trembling-lip.
    Er, realise I’ve gone on a bit and will understand if you delete this but you struck a cord!!

  50. EJ Avatar
    EJ

    Lovely rant and TOTALLY AGREE. This is why we love you!

Leave a Reply to HilaryCancel reply

Discover more from RANDOM JOTTINGS

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading