RANDOM JOTTINGS


A blog about music, sports, theatre and rants





After ploughing through A N Wilson's biography of Prince Albert I felt in need of a little light relief so I re-read a couple of Agatha Christie (Five Little Pigs and the Man in the Brown Suit) Enjoyed them all over again.  I also read several light romances, none of which I can remember now, which were light and frothy and very relaxing. I do love a romantic novel.

I picked up the latest Harry Hole book The Knife by Jo Nesbo which cannot be categorised as light reading. Throughout this series Harry has lurched from alcoholism to sobriety and back again and in this book we find he is once more hitting the bottle as his wife has slung him out. KnifeThere is a particular nasty murder very near home which sobers Harry up as he goes in search of the killer – he is pretty sure he knows Who Dun It. A rapist who has recently been released from prison who has a vendetta against Harry and his family.  The story of this repugnant man runs alongside the investigtion and Nesbo plays all the tricks in the book to try and make us think they are linked. The plot twists and turns and I can honestly say that when the murderer was revealed I was shocked as that person had never crossed my mind. Absorbing read even if it gets a bit near the knuckle at times in terms of violence.

Many Rivers to Cross – Peter Robinson. The latest Inspector Banks story all of which I have read with gradually decreasing enjoyment. The author likes rock music and music of the sixties and seventies and we are left in no doubt about this as he hauls playlists into every volume.  In the earlier tighter and tauter books this was very much on the periphery but in the later books it crept in and seemed to take over to the detriment of the narrative. I got the feeling that it was needed to pad out the story.

The latest starts with an incredibly artificial opening with two characters, one of whom featured in the last story, discussing the UK and Brexit and it is very clear from the discussion that Peter Robinson thinks we are all going to hell in a handcart that the country is racist and divided and an unpleasant place to live.  They then get stuck into Trump by which time I was getting very irritated.  I am not the slightest bit interested in the author's politics whether they agree with mine or not. When I purchase a detective story I do not expect a current affairs diatribe I want a good story and I want the writer to get on with it.  Despite my irritation I did read the book and felt, as I have the last two or three, that it was boring and I found myself skipping chunks to get to the end.

I am not alone most of the reviews on Amazon seem to say the same as me "The constant references to current affairs, most notably Brexit, appeared to be an opportunity for the author to bang a personal, opinionated, drum which I certainly don’t need from pleasure reading".

It is now in the charity shop bin and I do not think I will bother with any more by Mr Robinson.

To the Land of Long Lost Friends – McCall Smith. The latest in the interminable saga of the No 1 Ladies Detectve Agency which have now become pure whimsy and move at the pace of a sloth. I think the kindest word for this is meandering. I shall leave it there.

Anglican Women Novelists – edited by Maltby and Shell.  I have mentioned this before and was looking forward to reading it. Unfortunately it suffers from 'academic speak' so dense and long winded that you have to work really hard to work your way through the verbiage. Think Henry James multiplied by twenty and that will give you some idea.  The chapter on Noel Streatfield used the words 'nurture and nurturing' thirteen times with a few 'patriarchical' thrown in for good measure.  These essays made the subject matter sound dreary and boring and as they were covering Charlotte Bronte, Elizabeth Goudge and P D James to name a few, that takes some doing. Very disappointing.

I have just started the ghost stories of Edith Wharton. I have read many of these before but this is a lovely new edition from Virago and I will be writing about them nearer Halloween. They are wonderful.

And I raved about Eagle of the Ninth in an earlier post. This garnered lots of comments and one of my readers told me I MUST read Knight's Fee by Sutcliff. Well, I did and it reduced me to floods of tears. It was simply superb,

Posted in ,

10 responses to “Reading round up”

  1. Elaine Avatar

    I have the ghost stories in various baattered editions but having this new one is lovely. I shall be reviewing before the end of October

  2. Elaine Avatar

    I have it ready to go!

  3. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    I absolutely adore Edith Wharton and can’t wait for the Virago hardback as my own copy of her ghost stories is an old paperback and falling apart. Mind you, I think in general the Scribner paperbacks, light, flexible, lovely paper and covers, take a lot of beating.

  4. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    Oh Yes, the Brunetti series is feeling very tired nowadays…

  5. Karlene Avatar
    Karlene

    Knight’s Fee is tender and brave and wonderful. Try also Dawn Wind — one of Sutcliff’s few titles where a young girl plays an important role. It is my favorite of hers. One of her themes, the coming together of two disparate peoples, for example British and Saxons, is present in both titles.

  6. Reader Lane Avatar
    Reader Lane

    What an excellent winter reading project! I’m adding Knight’s Fee to my TBR list based on your sayso. It’s funny the power of the original illustrations to take us back in time, I find, even when I don’t remember remembering them until I see them again

  7. Elaine Avatar

    I have the lovely editions from Slightly Foxed which are beautiful and have the original illustrations. I managed to get hold of an old edition of Knight’s Fee which I remember as a child, the OUP edition. I was totally overwhelmed by it and thought it was marvellous and I was in tears at the end.
    I read her memoir some years ago but have reserved it at the library as I want a re-read. I think I might make Rosemary Sutcliff my reading for the winter.

  8. Elaine Avatar

    Hi Sue. the earlier Robinson novels were good but now they are just plain boring. I checked out the reviews on Amazon and they seem as one. I shan’t bother with him any more. Peter James series set in Brighton are going the same way. I suppose it is inevitable if you write a long running series that you are going to tire of writing them. Donna Leon the same.
    I almost fell asleep reading the McCall Smith.

  9. Reader Lane Avatar
    Reader Lane

    I’ve enjoyed Rosemary Sutcliffe as a child library reader, but you remind me I haven’t read many of her books, so I’ve got Eagle of the Nineth on order. Thanks for the tip. Do you know her memoir, Blue Remembered Hills? I read it a few years ago via the Open Library website and thought it was as good as her fiction with the insight into characters and sensitivity to landscape. She writes briefly of her treatments for rheumatoid arthritis as a child with what seemed to me remarkable acceptance of the pain and separation from her family involved.

  10. Sue Cuthbert Avatar
    Sue Cuthbert

    I gave up on Peter Robinson about 15 years ago!
    At least the sun always shines in Botswana and no mentions of Brexit

Leave a Reply

Discover more from RANDOM JOTTINGS

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading