RANDOM JOTTINGS


A blog about music, sports, theatre and rants





All Jane Austen fans will be eagerly looking forward to next Sunday when, in the UK anyway, a dramatisation of Sanditor is scheduled.  Any fragment by Jane that can be used in this way is seized upon with joy and I am very much looking forward to seeing what is going to be done with it.

Sanditon was left in manuscript at Jane Austen's death in July 1817 which ended at Chapter 12. So there is not much to deal with as with The Watsons (another fragment which will I am sure end up being dramatised at some stage).

In Sanditon, which was untitled when Jane died, she moves away from her usual setting of families in the countryside and writes, what Kathryn Sutherland in the OUP edition, calls "the first seaside novel".   In Emma we Sea know that she longs to visit the seaside but has yet to do so, in Persuasion we have the famous fall by Louisa Musgrove at Lyme Regis.and in Mansfield Park there is an episode where Fanny visits her family in Portsmouth.  Jane visited the seaside and there have been theories that Sanditon is Sidmouth in Devon but she is very vague aboaut the topography so hard to prove one way or the other.

OUP Classics have produced a new edition of Sanditon edited by Kathryn Sutherland who I have already mentioned.  She is a professor of English literature and Senior Research Fellow at St Anne's Oxford, and here she has written an extremely interesting introduction to the text. 

Another edition, recently published, is issued by Fentum Press in a rather delightful hard back edition and has an introductory essay by Janet Todd. Janet is the General Editor of the Cambridge Works of Jane Austen and also edits the Cambridge Companion to Pride and Prejudice. Another fascinating essay on the novel with beautiful colour illustrations throughout.  

here is a list of continuations at the end of the book and some of these I know, some I do not.  It seems a two hour film using Marie Dobbs completion was proposed but nothing has been heard since. Sandi

And it is to Marie Dobbs that I now turn. I have a copy of her continuation which was published in 1975 and it has been on my book shelves for years. I worked at Camden Libraries during this period and was sorting through a pile of books which had been withdrawn and were going to be pulped. When I spotted Sanditon I knew I could not allow it go and came home with it.  I rather enjoyed this version. Janet Todd says "it resembles Georgette Heyer's sort of romantic comedy (which is a good thing as far as I am concerned!) and drops the broad satire on medicine and invalid tourism of the Austen original".

Another lady

I also have to mention Set in the Silver Sea by Jane Austen and A Gentleman which I discovered by chance about a year ago. The author is one David Williams and seems to be self published. I have a copy awaiting my attention and the only reason I have yet to read it is that is enormous. Not a small paperback but the size of a coffee table book so not easy to hold and read.

The dramatisation coming up has been scripted by Andrew Davies who is famous for "sexing up" the classics as he puts it. While I am not decrying his use of the dive in the lake by Darcy in P & P, it can get a bit tiresome after a while as he does rather labour the point. About eighteen months ago Davies produced a dramatisation of War and Peace which was beautiful to look at, but oh so slow and dreary. He managed to introdue incest into it because he said that Tolstoy had hinted at it. Well, I was not about to re-read War and Peace to find out but it seemed to me to be stretching it a bit.

As Sanditon is set by the sea I am sure there will be plenty of Andrew Davies frolics on the shore and nude bathing, but no matter what I am looking forward to this immensely.

 

Posted in ,

14 responses to “Sanditon – Jane Austen”

  1. Sandy G Avatar
    Sandy G

    According to the teens I work with, which is where I got it from, it’s being pretentiously overly aware of things like social injustices and environmental issues, and making sure everyone knows you care. The verbal assault on Charlotte Heywood by Sidney Parker at the end of Ep 1 was full of it, all Andrew Davies and not Jane Austen!

  2. Margaret Powling Avatar

    I must seem rather dim, but what do you mean by “woke” dialogue, Sandy G? Please explain to this dimwit.

  3. Sandy G Avatar
    Sandy G

    Wasn’t it awful! Anne Reid was having way too much fun in her role, and also the only competent actress in it.- In an age where CGI can deliver realistic flying dragons, why couldn’t they manage decent buildings? A character with designer stubble and “woke” dialogue, implied incest (!) plus the odd choice of music for the ball made the whole thing a total mess. However, I may just go for Ep 2 to see how much worse it gets!
    As the poster above states, it pales in comparison to the wonderful Gentleman Jack, a series I actually watched all eight episodes of and then pre-ordered the DVD so I could watch it all again!

  4. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    I’m glad I decided to give it a miss after all:)

  5. Elaine Avatar

    I thought it was dire. Acting poor from the main ingenue, Anne reid as Lady Denham was wonderful. The music was so loud and I agree it drowned out the dialogue. CGI was pretty obvious as well. How they are going to drag this out over eight episodes I really do not knnow

  6. Elaine Avatar

    Well Jane I have to say that my initial response to your comment is not to worry. It is pretty poor stuff

  7. Elaine Avatar

    I may bail out as well. On the other hand, it might be good to see if it gets any worse

  8. Elaine Avatar

    A voice over before the first episode warned us on “some nudity and scenes of a sexual nature”. I just thought oh gawd here we go again with Andrew Davies. God he is so tedious with his obsession with sexing up the classics. It was borin

  9. Margaret Powling Avatar

    Watched this last night, Elaine, and both husband and I felt that, especially with the jaunty sound track, someone had taken note of the wonderful drama, Gentleman Jack, and thought that might ‘work’ here. Unlike Gentleman Jack, where the soundtrack really did enhance the action, in Sanditon it simply irritated and sometimes the soundtrack overwhelmed the words of the actors. That aside, I enjoyed it moderately I would say. I hadn’t read Sanditon, so am being open-minded as to Andrew Davies’ adaptation but unlike his P & P and the wonderful Persuasion with Amanda Root (my favourite adaptation) last night’s opening episode had shades of pantomine about it, baddy-woman-dressed-in-black, buffoon-obviously-fat, love-interest-immediately-at-odds-with-heroine, etc. And the ‘wet shirt’ scene was there for all to enjoy when the chaps ran naked into the ice-cold sea (but we only saw their backs, ha ha – Mr Davies chickened out by showing full frontal, ha ha!)
    I would also like to mention the use of CGI which gave some scenes a fairytale atmosphere, as if from a pretty children’s book. I’m all for CGI now and again, but we have seaside resorts that could’ve been used, especially Sidmouth and Lyme, so a pity these weren’t used but no doubt CGI cheaper.

  10. Jane Avatar

    Sorry for my typo. I guess I am way too excited to be able to type properly.

  11. Jane Avatar

    I am really looking forward to this. I don’t know when I can see it thought in the US, might take a while longer.

  12. Erika W. Avatar
    Erika W.

    I am very much in two minds about this…
    Meanwhile I have begun to read “Middle England” This is so good and I would never have found it without this blog. I spent a year working in England,in 1982, and it illuminates so much of it. I lived in what was nick-named The Gin and Jaguar Belt, in Hampshire, while working in outer London. So many types, but not cliches, are recognizable in Coe’s book. He is tongue in cheek but always kind and with the sensitive observation of a woman author (big compliment from me!)

  13. Sandy G Avatar
    Sandy G

    I plan to give the first episode a go, but if it’s at all like the recent Vanity Fair, I will bail out after that. I read recently that Andrew Davies said all the original Austen is in the first hour and after that it’s all him! We shall see, I will be interested to read what you think of it.

  14. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    I was going to avoid it like the plague but may well give it a go now on the strength of your view. For one thing, there’s so little of the original that I don’t have a fixed view of how it should be. Looking forward to your comments:)

Leave a Reply to Margaret PowlingCancel reply

Discover more from RANDOM JOTTINGS

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading