RANDOM JOTTINGS


A blog about music, sports, theatre and rants





"giving pleasure or satisfaction; pleasant or attractive:"

This is the dictionary definition of the word nice.  I feel that sometimes this particular word can be used in a derogatory manner or to intimate something bland and uninteresting.  But, as you can see from above, it can mean precisely what is says – giving pleasure or satisfaction.

As I get older I find that my interest in books that are described as "searing" "visceral" "stunning" "brutal" is nil. Even when younger I avoided titles so described because, quite frankly, why be made miserable?

Over my reading/blogging life I have been sent a huge assortment of books and have Nicestruggled with many of them. That is not to say they were not brilliant or well written. Au contraire, one can hardly level this kind of criticism at the likes of Margaret Atwood, Barry Unsworth, Kingsley Amis etc.   But I have never wanted or wished to return to them or to re-read them. Once is enough. I remember reading Possession by A S Byatt, a real tour de force but once I had finished it I felt a weariness of spirit and an exhaustion and I cannot say I enjoyed it. I might appreciate it but I did not love it.

And then I tried The Children's Book by the same author and honestly, I thought It. Would. Never. End.   This was one book that I really went to town on – I normally will not give a bad or withering review because I always remember that because I do not like a book does not mean others will feel the same. However, I was heartened after writing my post – here– by comments agreeing with me. I also felt that A S Byatt would hardly notice my thoughts.

So it is with a feeling of Sod it who cares that I now read Wot I Like. And Wot I Like turns out to be "nice" books.   I have not been well recently and also now have to deal with a bad hip and the likelihood that I will need an operation in the not too distant, and it is with relief that I have turned to relaxed reading.

When I worked at a library in Highgate, London many moons ago I was a teenager with skirts barely covering my bum, wearing boots and false eyelashes and full of myself.   The readers who came in were lovely but they were mainly of a certain age and would ask me for a "nice" book. I knew nothing but I did note that Miss Read and D E Stevenson featured largely in their choices, ditto Dorothy Whipple.   My nose was permanently turned up. But guess what I am reading at the moment – yep, Miss Read and D E Stevenson.  

Last year I read all the Thrush Green books by Miss Read.  There was an offer on Kindle for the whole lot some time back for the princely sum of 99p so I bought them and then forgot all about them.  And then one day I was feeling at a loose end and I opened then up and found all the wonderful illustrations were there too. I read them all over a week and absolutely loved them.   It also added to my pleasure when I discovered that the current price for the whole lot on Kindle was now nearly £40….

I have just started the Fairacre series and have most of them on my shelves waiting my attention.   This paragraph from The Village School made me laugh:

"I am heartily sick of books from Caxley library – all termed 'powerful' by their reviewers (and in future I shall steer clear of any with this label) which give the suffering reader a detailed account of the bodily functions of their main characters.  If the author has such a paucity of ideas that he must pad out his 300 pages with reiterated comments on his hero's digestive, alimentary and productive systems, I am sorry for him but do not see why he should be encouraged"

This could have come straight out of Diary of a Provincial Lady by E M Delafield (of which more another day).

I wrote about D E Stevenson a while back and here is the link. And I see I have used the word nice again!

And then D E Stevenson.  Over the last year or so I have read every single one. Her output was prodigious and, naturally, there are a few that I think are a bit poor and overwritten. Hardly surprising when you write so many and I daresay your publishers are breathing down your neck. But the vast majority of them are sheer delight and it is wonderful that they are now nearly all back in print. I remember a visit to Hay on Wye some while back when I was hunting second hand copies but now they are easy to find.  Dean Street Press have quite a few titles and Persephone Books have published the Miss Buncle books.  And the good thing about them is they pay rereading. I have not tired of doing so and reach for one when I need to be quiet and happy.

Dorothy Whipple was another popular author which made my nose turn up but oh how wrong I was.  Persephone Books now have all her titles in print and they are an eye opener. Yes, they are enormously entertaining and easy to read, but do not fall into the trap of thinking they are facile. They are not. They are positively Austenian in their dissection of human frailties and life.  See my earlier thoughts here

And then there is Richmal Crompton – author of the William books which dogged her all her life and which over shadowed her adult books.  Many of these long out of print titles are now available so another author to look out for.

So all Hail to Nice Books.  They should be given the respect they deserve. And don't start me on the way Romantic novels are treated.  That really gets my dander up. 

I once had an argument with a man (well it would be) who said they were a load of tripe and brought up the name Mills & Boon. I pointed out to him that they were a difficult publisher to persuade to publish your writing. I also said that most novelists are proud of producing a book a year. DId you know said I that with Mills & Boon you have to write three or four a year? Could you manage that? Did he have the discipline and the capacity to do so?  He weakly responded that they were all badly written at which point I got really cross and asked if he had read any. Of course he had not. I then asked him if he had read Dan Brown and he said yes. My response to this was that if he thought that was well written then he had no qualifications whatsoever to pontificate on romantic novels.

At this point he retired from the lists, with his wife who had been standing watching and listening, saying "I told you not to argue with Elaine"

Victory was mine.  Everyone should read what they want and not have to be sneered at by others. I admit I used to when I was young and stupid but no more.

This has turned into a bit of a rant. Do forgive me.

I am off to make a cup of tea and return to Fairacre.

Posted in , , ,

23 responses to “Thoughts on “nice” books”

  1. Elaine Avatar

    I thought both the Welsh and Scottish finalists were not in the same league as the others. I picked the bass from round one and was delighted with his win

  2. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    And like you, I thought the bass was stunning and had been rooting for him to win! I also thought the Scottish mezzo was excellent but would question her repertoire choices; she didn’t seem to me to have quite the personality for Va, tacito and by the time she got to Spectre she sounded tired. No doubt she’ll have a well-merited stellar career.

  3. Elaine Avatar

    Helen
    South Korean tenor Kim Sung-ho became the Song Prize winner at the BBC Cardiff Singer of the World competition held at St David’s Hall, Cardiff, on Sunday.
    I liked him so pleased!

  4. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    Hope you love it as much as I did. I’m enjoying a Very Happy Phase of ‘nice’ books at the moment.
    Quick question but nothing to do with the topic in hand! I’ve searched online of course but somehow can’t find out who won the song prize at Cardiff this year. Do you happen to know?

  5. Elaine Avatar

    I have just purchased the Kindle edition and thank you for the recommendation

  6. Elaine Avatar

    Hello Steve and good to read your comment. I can never understand attitudes to one’s reading choices. Was it somehow unmanly to like Miss Read? Why should you not read and enjoy them? I am glad you did not care!!
    There will be rants galore I can assure you…

  7. Steve Avatar
    Steve

    Thank you. I will give it a go when I finish my current reads.

  8. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    I’d like to recommend a modern (published this year) ‘nice book’ entitled Mrs. Hart’s Matrimonial Bureau by Sheena Wilkinson. Don’t be put off by the title, it’s brilliant. Set in 1934 it’s, well, read it and find out!

  9. Steve Avatar
    Steve

    As no other males seem to have commented on your post I have to ask if I am the only male that likes ‘nice’ books. I have loved Miss Read since my teens and am now past 70. D. E . Stevenson, Richmal Crompton et al love ‘em. I worked in a bookshop for many years and devoured many types of fiction and non fiction but my admission of my liking for Miss Read was something I never lived down. Good job I didn’t and still don’t care. Keep up the excellent posts, rants included.

  10. Elaine Avatar

    do try Whipple and if you do let me know what you think.

  11. Elaine Avatar

    I have been sorting out the Fairacre titles that I own and have a list of the missing ones. I went onto a second hand bookshop online and ordered eight and have got the remaining ones for the princely price of £23 and free postage!!

  12. Elaine Avatar

    Alias Grace nearly finished me off as well! well written and at the time I found it absorbing but, yet again, no desire to read any more.

  13. Elaine Avatar

    I have no compunction in not finishing a book these days

  14. Elaine Avatar

    yes her books have a beginning a middle and a happy ending and that is why I enjoy them so much. Who wants angst and misery. You have only just discovered her so you have many more happy hours ahead of you!

  15. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    Me too! But I love the narrative voice in the Fairacre books & the cast of regular characters.

  16. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    I’ve NEVER felt guilty about not finishing a book!

  17. Kate Canlis Avatar
    Kate Canlis

    Your post expressed exactly how I feel. It took me a while to get over feeling guilty and embarrassed for not reading “ literary/serious fiction.” When you run low on nice books , try Elizabeth Fair.
    Thank you for suggesting Dorothy Whipple.
    Kate

  18. Kimberly Howlett Avatar
    Kimberly Howlett

    I love the Thrush Green novels and have them all … not so keen on Fairacre, too many children. The Thrush Green characters are mostly retired people (as am I) getting on with village life, the incomers, some romance, so projects & one old dear that everyone looks out for … just retired myself & wish I lived there!

  19. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    I paraphrase but didn’t Pope(?) once write of ‘what oft was said but ne’er so well expressed’? My thoughts entirely! I delighted in this post because it does sum up many of my own feelings re ‘modern classics’. There have been some which appeal to me: one novel from a Women’s Prize shortlist called Vanishing Half, for example, and two older novels, The White Woman on the Green Bicycle and my book of the year so far Jim Crace’s Signals of Distress which I liked when it came out in the mid 90s and absolutely adored this time around. Why? because it had a strong and convincing storyline, credible characters, likeable and otherwise, and prose which, at the risk of sounding fanciful, positively dances on the page.
    That’s the rub for me. It’s true I’m fed up with endless books banging on about women being degraded and murdered etc and those where the politics take precedence over the plot & everything else; however, what I most dislike is clunky, dismal prose. I’m afraid I’d put Margaret Atwood in this category ( Alias Grace nearly killed me; it took two Dickens and a Jane Austen before I recovered my reading poise) along with Sarah Waters (feels like walking uphill through porridge) and oh, too many others to name. It seems to me that if your subject matter is fashionable enough or you’re the (current) darling of Literary London you can churn out almost anything and it will be well-reviewed.
    Well, like you, I say ‘no more’! I’ve just taken a two large bags of my latest brave Attempts at Modern Literature to the P.D.S.A shop and am planning a nice(!) relaxing afternoon of Melissa da Costa, a French writer who seems to be under the apparently erroneous impression that it’s the author’s job to please and interest the reader, not t’other way round.

  20. Ann Hall Avatar
    Ann Hall

    Couldn’t agree more. And I no longer feel guilty if I do mot finish a book.

  21. Debbie Avatar
    Debbie

    I read a D E Stevenson recently (The House on the Cliff) and loved it. However, I kept expecting horrible things to happen to the heroine and bracing myself for it – but nothing untoward took place. Ooooh. I then began to question what it said about me that I “expected” and prepared for nastiness to occur in the novel. Is it reading too much crime fiction perhaps? (I loved that it was a straightforward story and will seek out more: it restored my faith in human nature…and books).
    Yours baffled

  22. Elaine Avatar

    I have a Ruby Ferguson lurking somewhere. Ditto O Douglas. Just seek them out

  23. diana Avatar

    Amen to the above! And here are some more treasures to brighten a day: Apricot Sky by Ruby Ferguson and do try O Douglas. My favourites are The proper Place , The day of small things and Pink Sugar.

Leave a Reply to Kate CanlisCancel reply

Discover more from RANDOM JOTTINGS

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading