RANDOM JOTTINGS


A blog about music, sports, theatre and rants





Earlier this year at the Felixstowe Book Festival I chaired An Afternoon of Romance. It was great fun. On the panel we had a Jane Austen expert, a writer of Romances which are published and sold on Amazon, and a Mills & Boon writer who had written over 75 titles for them.

After the afternoon was over I was challenged by somebody attending the Festival who said what tripe romance was and how this person had sat on a beach once, no doubt after a few bevvies, reading out from Mills & Boon and being sarcastic. My hackles rose immediately and I launched into a full frontal assault on this person's snobbish attitude and scorn for the genre, pointing out that there was good and bad writing across all forms of the novel and I had read some pretty crap stuff in my time in the detection/thriller/so called modern literature formats and I would defend to the death the idea of the romantic novel. I was incensed by this attitude and it is an attitude which romantic writers have to put up with all the time.   Indeed, the Mills  Boon author told me she had been asked 'when are you going to write proper books?' and also advised to 'keep that quiet if I were you' when she said who she was published by.

I doubt that the person who I had this debate with could even write a short story let a lone a novel. And, as I pointed out, if you were lucky enough to have your work accepted by Mills & Boon, and they are hard task masters, you do not have long to preen yourself and think how wonderful, three months later they want another one and then another and then another. Romantic novelists are very hardworking.

I cannot bear snobbery in literature I really cannot. However, I freely admit that I would never be seen in public reading a Dan Brown…. worst writer in the world in my opinion and yet nobody pours scorn on him (well the book critics might) and his books sell in millions and nobody turns their nose up at them. And they should. They are AWFUL.

Over the last few months, my regular trawls at book fairs and charity shops have thrown up a bumper collection of romance for me. I am sure I have written about Mary Burchell before, but will do so again, as she is a most interesting woman. Her real name is Ida Cook and she and her sister, both opera lovers, travelled all over Europe visiting various opera houses. This was pre-war and they became very well know as they always wore fur coats and lots of jewellery and made friends in every airport and city they visited. During WW2 they continued these visits, even to Germany, where they were regarded as those Eccentric English Women and were allowed through. Sewn into their fur coats and smuggled in were more jewels and money which was passed onto those helping the Jews get out of the country. They continued doing this for years and, after the war, Mary carried on writing for Mills & Boon and all proceeds of her books went to supporting refugees from the war. She also wrote a wonderful biography of my favourite baritone, Tito Gobbi and became a great friend of his.

IMG_4159

IMG_4160

Her earlier books were products of their time.   The man patronised the women, the 'little woman' saw nothing wrong with this and knew their place. Later on, her books took a stronger line and the heroines began to flex their muscles, go out to work and not put up with being patronised.  Her books from the sixties onward reflected the change in society and also had opera as a background. I really enjoyed these as it is clear she knew her stuff and what she was writing about and had a knowledge of music. She wrote a series which Endeavour Press have recently re-issued as the Warrender Saga, featuring a rather despotic conductor and if he is not based on Karajan I will eat my baton.   Tremendous fun and I loved them.

IMG_4159-001

In the photos you will see the covers and how they have changed over the years.  You will also see three books discovered at a book fair last year by Hermina Black, Renee Shann and, again, Mary Burchell.  I remember reading Black and Shann as a teenager and found them pretty unreadable now. The male character in the Romance for Romany title says, at one stage, 'you know you really deserve a good slap'……shock horror

Iris Bromige is another author who I loved in my teens but who I now find difficult to take. All the male protagonists in her books are frighteningly superior and arrogant and have an awful habit of calling the heroine 'Little one', 'My child' or 'My dear' until you want to clock them one.

But as our lovely Mills & Boon author pointed out when she spoke at Felixstowe, the books published by that house reflect the changing times. I now feel that they may have gone a bit too far in the other direction as, quite frankly, some of them verge on the pornographic to be blunt, and they seem to be obsessed with Millionaires and Billionaires and Fascinating Greeks.   And, sad to see, many of the women, though holding down jobs, running companies and operating a business still seem very quick to succumb to a powerful male.  I suppose we all want some wish fulfillment in our lives and dream of a Darcy type figure sweeping us off our feet.

Not sure that I do actually but until it happens I really cannot be sure…..

But long live Romance and sneery snobby derogatory people had better steer clear of me that is all I can say.

Now back to my pile of dog eared romances which are awaiting my attention.

Posted in ,

16 responses to “Romantic Reading – Random Thoughts”

  1. Elaine Avatar

    I used the example of Ida Cook to prove that not all romantic writers are poor writers or airheads who only write romance because they cannot write anything else. I get so mad at this attitude

  2. Christine Poulson Avatar
    Christine Poulson

    Really enjoyed this, Elaine. A good read is a good read whatever the genre. I am with you all the way on Dan Brown. Fascinated by the Ida Cook story – what a woman!

  3. Elaine Avatar

    Hi Julie I don’t mind the odd billionaire but prefer the more mainstream stories. My favourite out of all the writers is Catherine George but she has not written for a while now and I realised the other day that she must be about seventy as her earlier books were written in the eighties. It is a shame. When I contacted M&B and asked about her they were very evasive….
    No I love romance and, as you say,110 years old they are doing pretty well. Bet other publishers and authors wished they had their longevity

  4. Elaine Avatar

    I tried the Da Vinci Code but gave up after three pages I could not believe how bad it was. A comment above has mentioned James Patterson – well I have just read a couple of his over the weekend, got them from the library, and really the standard of writing is pretty poor. Of course this depends on his co-writer. So when people get sniffy and Mills & Boon I get extremely irritated. I really went for the person who was being so derogatory!

  5. Julie Avatar

    I love Mills and Boon and loathe people who look down their noses at them – especially if they haven’t read a book in years. There are some wonderful writers writing for M&B these days. Their historical romance line is marvellous and I do adore the Medical, Modern and Cherish lines and I must admit to a soft spot for billionaire Italian heroes as well. M&B are an escape and a wonderful way to unwind after a hard day or just when you want to lose yourself in an uplifting romance. Next year will be M&B’s 110th anniversary, so they must be doing something right!

  6. Sue Hatherell Avatar
    Sue Hatherell

    Very good post, well done on championing M&B. I too hate book snobs and I 100% agree about Dan Brown, what dreadful, dreadful writing and yet the man has made millions – why? I really, really enjoy your blog, such wit. Also like your posts on Strictly. Sue H

  7. Elaine Avatar

    Yep agree. My ex used to say to me How can you read that rubbish after you have just read Dickens/Austen etc/. I just replied quite easily thank you and ignored him. Not sure that he ever read a book in his life. All he read were opera scores….

  8. Elaine Avatar

    Actually you have picked on an author of whom I have a low opinion. James Patterson comes up with the plots but the writing is done by somebody else but marketed under his name and I think that is cheating. The books vary wildly and the Alex Cross ones are really nauseatingly sentimental. But, I read some of them and enjoy them and Strongly defend anybody who wants to read for pure pleasure.
    But I still draw the line at Dan Brown……

  9. Elaine Avatar

    I used to love Jilly Cooper but cannot read her now. I enjoyed her most when she used to write for the Times years ago. Her column was always a joy

  10. Elaine Avatar

    This whole attitude gets me so angry. The chicklit genre receives the same scorn though I think the general presentation of these books and covers invites it. There are some damn good writers there

  11. Elaine Avatar

    A brave and interesting woman and rather knocks the theory on the head that if you write romances you are dim

  12. Desperate Reader Avatar

    Absolutely agree, and one of the things I like about M&B is their workmanlike attitude. Yes, the books are often formulaic, but romance is hardly the only genre that does that, or encourages books to be written at almost production line levels of efficiency, and at least they’re pretty honest about what you’re getting. There are days when that’s exactly what you want though, and there’s nothing wrong with that.

  13. Travellin Penguin Avatar

    I heard an interview with James Paterson. He puts up with the same crap. His answer was, “I can’t do great literature but I can do crime and it sells in the millions.” I feel if you can do something well it should not matter what it is. He is laughing all the way to the bank. I heard a woman say “no great loss” when Bryce Courtenay died”. He gave Australian history to a lot of previous non readers or lower lit people readers and he took all the time in the world to sign books and talk to people. Not everyone wants to read “proper literature” and much of it is high brow tripe.. people should read what they want without fear of ridicule. At least they are reading and getting pleasure. What else is it about? I’m with you,

  14. Nicola Avatar

    ‘Fraid I’m not keen on M&B but I will admit to a Jilly Cooper habit!

  15. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    I’m with you all the way on this one. We’re just more versatile then the snobs.

  16. Diana Birchall Avatar
    Diana Birchall

    Wonderful post! You tell ’em, Elaine! I must try a Mary Burchell – great description of her life. Enjoyed this very much!

Leave a Reply to Travellin PenguinCancel reply

Discover more from RANDOM JOTTINGS

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading