RANDOM JOTTINGS


A blog about music, sports, theatre and rants





In my life I have watched some marvelous adaptations on TV that I have never forgotten. These stretch back some time. Is there anybody here who remembers the Count of Monte Cristo starring Alan Badel? I remember seeing this on one of our first television sets, fifteen inch screen and in black and white. There used to be a slot on Sundays at 5.30pm and this was always the time for a 'classic' serial such as the Count and Nicholas Nickleby, Great Expectations, Oliver Twist and many more and I watched them all. The BBC was always regarded as the home of such dramatisations and then BBC2 came along and their first such was Middlemarch with Michelle Dotrice playing Dorothea and many more afterwards.

We all have our cherished memories of our favourites and I am pretty sure that Wolf Hall is now going to join the pantheon of Great Television.  I will be honest and say that I failed with the first book. I tried it three times and simply could not get on with it and gave up in the end. I also have to say that I find Hilary Mantel's personality somewhat abrasive which also did not make me feel I had to make a further effort. And in case you want to know why I do not care for her and the reason, well there is no hope of a rational reply. Just one one Cromthose things and I know full well that if I only read books by writers I liked or who were warm and cuddly, I would soon find myself in difficulties. 

Wolf Hall was trailed so extensively by the Beeb that I began to feel well Sod You I am not going to watch it but realised that this would be a severe case of Nose Cutting so tuned in fully prepared to switch off after ten minutes. I nearly did but something made me hold off from waving the remote. And boy am I glad I did.  By the end of the first episode I was 75% certain I was liking it and then a re-watch on iPlayer confirmed that this was bloody good. By the end of the second hour, well that was it, totally hooked.

So where to start?  The beginning is a very good place to start (pace Julie Andrews):   the casting. Here again I have to say I had my doubts having seen Mark Rylance as Henry V at the Globe and being left fairly unmoved. He has never been somebody I felt I had to watch, he is now.  So quiet, so still the slightest eye movement, lift of an eyebrow or a look expressing so much. The only other actor who does this so well is Michael Kitchen in Foyle's War.  Then Damien Lewis as Henry. Not too bluff, not too domineering at first but the outburst of rage at the French Ambassador, the chilling coolness and antipathy towards Anne Boleyn and that final shot of the series where he embraces Cromwell after the execution of Anne and the close up of his evil gloating face. Shiver. And that execution scene left me totally drained….

The entire cast was brilliant and full of British thesps all making acting look so easy it was seamless. The candlelit interiors, the feeling that we were watching people going about their business, not knowing that from a historical point of view they would never be forgotten, that the despised Elizabeth would be one of our greatest Queens (Rylance made this point in the talk after the final episode), just getting on with day to day life.  Dam

Music – yes there was music but for most of each episode it was non existent. The scenes where the protagonists spoke to each other and plotted and planned was done with no background orchestration or violins or rolling drums or anything of that kind.  This made it even easier to concentrate and to understand what was going on and I found myself sitting forward totally involved and listening to every word. It gave the viewer a total theatrical experience and was quite spellbinding.   BBC please note.

I have not mentioned any of the other actors simply because if I did this post would go on for pages. Just take it from me that there was not a duff performance anywhere from anybody.

Many of my readers are based in the USA and elsewhere and this will be coming your way in due course. Please do not miss.

Simply superb and I am now going to have another crack at the books.

And as a footnote, I would love to hear if any of you have a memorable TV series you remember from years back which has always stayed with you. Apart from the aforementioned Count of Monte Cristo, the 1973 War and Peace with Anthony Hopkins and Alan Dobie has stayed with me, ditto Derek Jacobi in I, Claudius.   Do let me know.

Posted in ,

28 responses to “Wolf Hall – TV adaptation”

  1. Joanna Avatar
    Joanna

    Looking forward to this in the US in April – have been undecided if I should read it first or after watching this production? My daughter has read and liked it (as well as the sequel) so we’ll see.
    As for remembered series, Brideshead Revisited, Sherlock Holmes with Jeremy Brett and Pride and Prejudice with Colin Firth (although I also have fond memories of the earlier BBC version of Pride and Prejudice!)

  2. Lyn Avatar

    Yes, Eric Porter was Karenin. I’ll never forget him cracking his knuckles! Poor man, he didn’t have a clue. EP was so good in that, particularly the scene when Anna thinks she’s dying & he forgives Vronsky, very moving.

  3. Elaine Avatar

    As I said in my post Mary I was not sure I was going to like it but it gradually drew me in and then I was hooked. We will agree to differ!

  4. Elaine Avatar

    Brideshead Revisited was not for me, Jewel in the Crown wonderful and oh Smileys People, a masterpiece

  5. Elaine Avatar

    Now I never fancied Robin Ellis, yes I am in aminority, but am looking forward to the new one

  6. Elaine Avatar

    The original FOrsyte Saga was stunning and Eric Porter as Soames outstanding. I always felt sorry for Soames and could not stand Irene who drove me mad. Of course Damien Lewis was Soames in the remake and very good he was too

  7. Elaine Avatar

    That Janey Eyre was before we had a telly but I do remember seeing a bit of it somewhere

  8. Elaine Avatar

    Ok I will now have to try it! Two recommends from Random Readers so I should listen and take note…

  9. Elaine Avatar

    I claudius was a landmark series. I would be interested in how it has held up. Glad I am not the only one who found Wolf Hall hard to get into

  10. Elaine Avatar

    It is also written in the present tense Joan with which I have difficulties and, I too, found it confusing. Might give it another whirl though after this. This adaptation was masterley

  11. Elaine Avatar

    Oh Lyn I remember the Karenina with Nicola Pagett. Eric Porter was in that wasn’t he? Loved Serve them all my Days and that particular Jane eyre, Lord Wimsey of course, and Miss Marple yes and yes to Suchet too!

  12. Elaine Avatar

    On the whole Sarah I am not a fan of audio books as the voice never seems to fit my idea of the characters but perhaps as this is a book I have not read, it might work. I will try it and see.

  13. Elaine Avatar

    Let me have your thoughts on it when you see it Pam!

  14. Elaine Avatar

    it is one of the best things I have seen, Downton is rubbish, OK enjoyable rubbish and I love it, but still rubbish. This is something different

  15. Elaine Avatar

    I follow a lot of the blogs on the Guardian and they are always interesting and funny with insightful comments. The blog on Strictly come Dancing is particularly enjoyable!

  16. Mary Jenkins Avatar

    Sorry! I don’t usually disagree with you Elaine but I couldn’t get into the TV version of Wolf Hall! I struggled through two and a half episodes and then gave up! I haven’t read either of the books but perhaps listening to them would be an option? May I say that on canvassing friends, most of them thought the same as me, that it was dark, slow and rather boring and they didn’t think the actress playing Anne was right! We must be a low brow lot? Oh – I should mention that two of my friends are Production Designers and one criticised the costumes! Mind you they are both very critical of lots of things that pass over my head!

  17. Hilary Avatar
    Hilary

    Brideshead Revisited and Jewel in the Crown,also Smiley’s People which I have just watched for the first time.

  18. Annabel Avatar

    The first Poldark for me – Robin Ellis then – swoon. Am awaiting the new version with anticipation though.

  19. Gillie Avatar

    I’m back…..what about the original Forsyte Saga, or even the more recent one? The 60s one was shown, I think, on Sunday afternoons, and brought the UK to a standstill ……well, almost! Must try to get to grips with listening to books……

  20. Margaret Powling Avatar
    Margaret Powling

    No doubt I will eventually buy the DVDs of this series. I know it’s good, I know I shall like it, but I’ve not yet read the books and I prefer to read the books first.
    As for early drama serials, my earliest memory is of Jane Eyre when Rochester was played by a young Stanley Baker.

  21. Virginia Avatar
    Virginia

    I second the comment that recommended listening to books that are difficult to read. I had no trouble at all with either Wolf Hall or Bring Up the Bodies – loved them both – even so I loved the audible versions. And I could not get on with The Goldfinch…but loved it on CD. I now routinely give a book I’m struggling to read another chance on CD. Listening expands my range.

  22. Karen K. Avatar

    I was waffling about whether or not I should watch this, but now your review has convinced me to give it a try. I’ve flipped through the book at the library and I don’t think I have the patience to attempt her prose, but I think I’d really like the show.
    I’ve never seen I, Claudius but finally got around to reading the book last year. I’ve heard so many great things about the series I’ll have to put it on my list.

  23. Joan Kyler Avatar

    I respect your comments and reviews on books (and other things), so I’m relieved to read that you tried three times with Wolf Hall the book and couldn’t continue. I failed (or did the author fail?) with Wolf Hall, too, and thought there was something wrong with me because everyone else seemed to be raving about it. I found her writing confusing and difficult to follow. I’ve also read some of her comments that put me off her. I’m looking forward to Wolf Hall the TV version, especially after reading your review. Here in the US, it’s to be shown on PBS on starting on April 4th.

  24. Lyn Avatar

    I’ve ordered the DVDs as I don’t know when it will be shown here & I’m so glad that I won’t have to sit through the endless previews. Our ABC does it just as much as your BBC & it drives me mad. It’s put me off so many series. Favourite classics series – Anna Karenina with Nicola Pagett, To Serve Them All My Days with John Duttine, Jane Eyre with Zelah Clarke & Timothy Dalton, Wuthering Heights with Ian McShane (although I only saw this on DVD not when originally released), Lord Peter Wimsey with Edward Petherbridge & Harriet Walter, Miss Marple with Joan Hickson, early series of Poirot with David Suchet – I could go on & on!

  25. Sarah Wrightson Avatar
    Sarah Wrightson

    Elaine, may I suggest you try listening to Wolf Hall? I felt completely surrounded by the book, and avoided the problems some had of not knowing who was speaking by the change in vocal patterns. I read the second, and loved it too. Can’t wait to see this, and thank you for the review.

  26. Pam Avatar
    Pam

    I’m one of the ones in the USA impatiently waiting to see this. I also struggled with the first book but once I became accustomed to the rhythm? of her writing I really enjoyed it and thought the second book was even better. So thankful for the BBC productions we are able to watch through public television or on Netflix, etc.

  27. Gillie Avatar

    Oh, definitely looking forward to it……do feel somewhat the same re HM! I agree about trailing….when we lived back in the UK, Downton was just beginning and Classic FM went completely overboard on Maggie Smith one liners til I was fed up to the back teeth and refused to watch it. Go forward to Christmas 2014 in Wyoming to find Only Son hooked on it and there was no question of not watching it…..guess what, we both love it……!
    Happy Belated Birthday, Elaine!

  28. Sarah Orr Avatar
    Sarah Orr

    Yes a wonderful programme.I also found the guardian recaps added to the pleasure.The recaps themselves were full of errors but the below the line comments were erudite and witty.

Leave a Reply to Joan KylerCancel reply

Discover more from RANDOM JOTTINGS

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading