RANDOM JOTTINGS


A blog about music, sports, theatre and rants





Just before Christmas I read 'Poirot and Me' by David Suchet. I have to say straight away that Mr Suchet is a superb actor but perhaps not so good a writer. Not that it matters in the slightest, his portrayal of Dame Agatha Christie's Hercule Poirot is the definitive one as far as I am concerned. Peter Ustinov and Albert Finney are insignificant compared to his portrayal.

I found it fascinating to read about his method of donning the character and the way he did it and also the changes of direction in the filiming as personnel changed.   The first few series were bang on the money as far as the stories and protagonists were concerned (though the portrayal of Miss Lemon was always wrong), but the slant began to vary somewhat as the series continued over the years with changes to the story line that were really not needed and extra suspects popping up.  More money was also spent on them as it was clear that the audience for this series was guaranteed.

It is a superb achievement and the TV company involved is to be congratulated in filming the entire ouevre with one actor. I cannot imagine anybody but Suchet now as Porot just as Joan Hickson is THE Miss Marple for me. More about that another day.

After finishing this book I went to my bookshelves and picked up an Agatha as I had a compulsion to read one of hers again. After reading it and thoroughly enjoying it I decided that this year I would re-read all her books again. DameWell, perhaps not all. Some of her later ones are rather vague and long winded, hardly surprising as she got older, and will be avoided but I intend to work my way through the rest*. Apart from the Marple and Poirot stories Dame Agatha wrote many stand alone books, some of which may not be so universally as popular as her two main Tecs, and I intend to give these a little bit more sunshine than hitherto.

Checked online to see if there were any free downloads but the Christie estate is a canny one and though I can get them if I join some organisation and give them my soul, I think I will be ordering most of them from the library as the prices on Amazon are also fairly high for a Kindle book.   Oddly enough I do not find many Agathas in charity shops, loads of Connelly, Patterson, Brown et al but very few Christie. Perhaps they are keepers and the others are not?

I have already read three titles since the New Year as you can see by my sidebar, these were ones I already had on my shelves and will write about those in due course.

So off I go – I very rarely get involved in reading challenges of any sort as I inevitably fall by the wayside but think I will be ok with this one.

If you have a favourite Christie do let me know.

*please see the comment left below by Renata about the possibility that Dame Agatha may have had the beginnings of Alzheimers when she was still writing so my comment is not really warranted, My apologies dear Agatha….

Posted in

20 responses to “Agatha revisited”

  1. Elaine Avatar

    Oh yes I remember the first time I read that I was gobsmacked. Lot of readers were cross about it and accused AC of cheating!

  2. jill Avatar

    My favourite book is The Murder of Roger Ackroyd ,with its very unreliable narrator!

  3. Elaine Avatar

    I love those early books and have just read Man in the Brown Suit and will be writing about that soon

  4. Elaine Avatar

    The Mary Westmacott books are interesting. One of them is really autobiographical as it is quoted extensively in a biog of AC later. I am not overly fond of most of them but they show Christie in a different light and are well worth reading

  5. Elaine Avatar

    Mystery of the Blue Train was one of her poorer ones I agree. Orient Express bowled me over the first time I read it and left me gasping.

  6. Elaine Avatar

    I totally disagree with the plot mechanic slur. She is spot on with her characterizations as far as I am concerned. And yes, her observations about human nature are shrewd. Witness miss Marple

  7. Joy Avatar
    Joy

    I’ve always loved Poirot and you are right, David Suchet is the definitive Poirot. I have always loved The Man in the Brown Suit and The Secret of Chimneys best of her non Poirot/Miss Marple books.

  8. Margaret @ BooksPlease Avatar

    I’ve been reading my way AC’s books over the last few years – there are many I love and inevitably others that aren’t as good. The last one I read is Towards Zero, which I thought was very good, although with a few reservations (I’ve written about it on my blog). I have ten left to read to complete my reading, although I haven’t read any of her Mary Westmacott books – yet. I haven’t found any of her books in charity shops – maybe a sign of her continuing popularity, but I have bought several in secondhand bookshops and even better in Barter Books, which is not too far from me, fortunately.

  9. Susan D Avatar

    I think Christie is the perfect author to curl up with, especially as this long winter is settling in again (here in Ontario and elsewhere). I have so many, tucked away in a box because my shelves are seriously overloaded) and yet recently when I went through them all to see what I didn’t have, I found many of the paperbacks I had over the years have vanished. Hmmm….
    Yes, some are much better than others (and no need, I think, to apologise for not really liking the last handful, because, whatever the cause, the AREN’T up to her classic brilliance). I recently reread Murder on the Orient Express and loved every syllable of it (and watched the 1974 film, a work of art) and then read Mystery of the Blue Train (1928) and found it a poor example of her plotting and characterisation (except the main protagonist, who deserved a better story) Even the semi-obligatory romance was seriously offensive to me.
    Sorry, I’m getting carried away)
    Anyway, I love to pick up a vintage Christie and dive in. One of my favourites is Sleeping Murder, published posthumously but written during WWII, and is a classic mystery in every way.
    Of course, there are many Christie sites to help you on your journey. If you don’t already have a comprehensive checklist, you can download one here:
    https://dsmith77.wordpress.com/2008/05/13/agatha-christie-novels-checklist/

  10. Ellie Elliott Avatar
    Ellie Elliott

    I really like The Hollow – that’s the one I most look forward to re-reading. I think it’s the one that most resembles her non-detective stories, in that the focus is really on characters and how people tick rather than the whodunnit aspect (though it’s still a very good Poirot in that sense too).
    She gets a lot of stick for being just a plot mechanic but her observations about human nature can be incredibly shrewd.

  11. Elaine Avatar

    I have picked up a few old ones recently with awful covers but I love them. I think Five Little Pigs is one of my top favorites but love Murder on the OE
    I am so sorry about your pain Linda, it must be simply awful. I get irritable if I have a headache and whiny and moany so heaven knows what I would be like if something really awful was wrong with me
    lots of love
    xx

  12. Elaine Avatar

    Hello Ruby Rose, what a lovely name. Cat Among the Pigeons is one of my favourites too. Oddly enough in one of her later books which I have just read, The Third Girl, Meadowfield is mentioned as one of the characters went there

  13. Elaine Avatar

    The Mysterious Mr Quinn is one of those favourites that I want to highlight as I think they are out of this world and slightly eerie. Love them. One of her stand alone books I think is excellent is Crooked House

  14. Elaine Avatar

    Final Curtain was brilliantly done and I think the fact that Hastings was there in that story added to it. In the book he says how touching he has found the interaction with all the fans. I am very fond of Suchet, I get the feeling that he is a kind and caring man and that is why his portrayal of HP was so good as HP is the same. Since posting this two or three of my friends who have vast Christie collections have offered to lend me the lot!

  15. Elaine Avatar

    Ah thanks for this Renata. That explains a lot. I should be more charitable but I remember reading these when I was so much younger and being disappointed in them. I will add a caveat to my post

  16. Linda Gillard Avatar

    I’m a big Agatha fan and I collect the pb editions with the stylish-but-ghoulish covers from the 60s designed by Tom Adams. I’ve also bought some beautiful Folio editions of Poirot & Marple books. My favourite is MURDER ON THE ORIENT EXPRESS (and the new Folio edition is just gorgeous.)
    Despite the gruesome subject matter (she was very knowledgeable about poisons!), I find Agatha restful and restorative. I suffer from chronic pain but her books distract me and occupy my brain, like a good crossword puzzle.

  17. Ruby Rose Scarlett Avatar

    I read them all in one year too! That was two years ago. My favourite is Cat Among the Pigeons – I absolutely love boarding school mysteries – and as much as I enjoy Murder on the Orient Express, the adaptation is an enormous improvement on the book in my opinion and a true masterpiece as it really explores the ethical dilemna that the resolution is. I hope you enjoy reading them all this year, I sure did!

  18. litlove Avatar

    I’m a huge Agatha fan – read them all when I was 13-14 and will occasionally reread for comfort. I agree that Suchet and Joan Hickson were the perfect Poirot and Marple, and no one will surpass them. As for favourites, the book of Murder on the Orient Express is actually amazingly good and very moving (I have the audiobook version, which David Suchet narrates brilliantly, too). And out of the more obscure ones, I really like The Mysterious Mr Quinn. Christie was a wonderful short story writer.

  19. sogalitno Avatar

    watched a fascinating interview with Suchet on the night of a screening of FINAL CURTAIN. i dont remember who aired it – but it was the debut of FINAL CURTAIN in the US.
    anyway the interview and then audience questions was wonderful. his rappaport with the audience (some very enthusiastic fans) was touching and admirable… he talked about his path in creating the role – one thing i loved that he mentioned – when he started the first set of HP he sat down and read ALL the stories and novels and every fact or note about HP and his characteristics, history etc he wrote down – he said the binder is huge now – and that was before they knew they would be filming all of the works.
    i agree that he and Hickson embody both of those characters (i have not watched any of the latest set of Marples- while i admire and like MacKenzie – NOT as Marple and i am finding the changing of the stories and adding characters etc to be very distracting and often disastrous)
    i may join you on your journey – have never read all of them either – i have many in hard/paper back but agree about the KINDLE prices. do watch as i have grabbed a few when Kindle has sales – will advise you if that happens (i got all of D Sayers for about 1 each in 2013 right before christmas!)

  20. Renata Avatar
    Renata

    A study done at University of Toronto by Ian Lancashire (I believe) did a textual analysis of the vocabulary of Christie’s works. As I remember it was strongly suggested that she was starting to suffer mental decline (Alzheimers?)at the end of her career. This is based on a much decreased variety of words compared with earlier works. I wonder if that explains your comment that her later things are vague and long-winded.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from RANDOM JOTTINGS

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading