RANDOM JOTTINGS


A blog about music, sports, theatre and rants





Only discovered these recently.  Picked up one or two from the library and thought I would give them a whirl and found myself really enjoying them.   Usual scenario of course, divorced detective now living on his own etc etc but this doesn't worry me any more, this marital set up is a given in this genre.

I have now read several of them and have found them well plotted, well written and well characterised. Won't say that I rushed out to read them all in one mad binge as I normally do, but they are ones I now keep an eye out for and was also pleased when the latest one Watching in the Dark was sent to me and very good it was too.  My sister loves these books so when I mentioned in passing that I had the latest Inspector Banks she said oh yes please and it is now residing in her book case.

So as I said good stuff, but not world shattering until I picked up In a Dry Season in a local charity shop, 20p – a bargain I am sure you will agree and sat down with my morning coffee and book. And there I stayed for the next two hours as I read solidly totally unable to put it down so engrossed was I.  It all starts with a young boy exploring an old reservoir under which lurked the remains of a village engulfed in the waters many years ago.  No surprise for readers when he stumbles across a skeleton and as it is buried and covered over with slate it is clear that it was hoped  it would never be found.

Tke skeleton is that of a young woman in her twenties and research indicates she was murdered just after the Second World War.  So Inspector Banks and DC Annie Cabot start tracing her life and who she is
Dryand how she met her death.   I am giving nothing away by telling you that her name was Gloria, she was a Land Girl sent to a remote Yorkshire village and there she met and fell in love with Matthew who she married and who then went off to war.

In a Dry Season has one of my favourite forms of narrative, the shifting backwards and forwards in time, between Gloria's life and back to today.   The description of the war time life in a remote village is fascinating and beautifully drawn: "we held the reception in the church hall….we only got two ounces of tea which we had to eke out with some of our own ration to make it drinkable.  Luckily our first American food on lend-lease had just arrived in the shop so we had Spam for sandwiches, and tinned sausage meat, which was wonderful for making sausage rolls because you could also use the fat left in the tin to make the pastry"

It is clear that though Gloria's parents were killed in the Blitz in London and that she is all alone in the world,  she has a secret in her past which she wishes to keep hidden and the reader, beguiled by Gloria's warmth and loving attitude to life, is left wondering if this is all on the surface and will something nastier emerge?   You are never sure and when a band of Americans arrive at the local air base and relationships grow between them and the villagers I found I was wondering all the time what was going to happen next.

I thought this was far and away the best of all the Peter Robinson books that I have read so far.  OK I have about another eight or nine to read but this particular title stood out for me.  As with Reginald Hill whose earlier books I found fairly banal and uninteresting, my first foray into DCI Banks made me feel the same – perhaps this was the book when he hit his stride.  I know that Death's Jest Book by Hill seemed to me to take a gigantic leap forward in terms of narrative and depth and, without wishing to descent into hyperbole, wonder if In a Dry Season fits the same bill.   I have no idea at all, obviously, but it is wonderful when a book really grips you in the way this one has.

Have noted that out of the 36 reviews over on Amazon, 27 of them are five star.  Well deserved say I.

Posted in

25 responses to “The Inspector Banks books of Peter Robinson”

  1. Elaine Avatar

    I am working my way through them from the library and picking some up the local charity shop. I am really enjoying them though reading them wildly out of order as usual

  2. anne Avatar
    anne

    over all, I enjoyed it. Ending was unlooked for, and yet, not. Rather like the Banks character, and Annie as well. May have to pursue this author further, thru interlibrary loan.

  3. Elaine Avatar

    Amazing that two or three of you have discovered this book in your possession just as I write about it. Looking forward to your thoughts on this and the JK

  4. Lisa Guidarini Avatar

    I found it! I did! I posted about today’s book haul on my blog and In a Dry Season was one of them! I’m pleased and have two books to finish ahead of it – including the JK Rowling The Casual Vacancy – then I’ll start it.
    Yay!

  5. Elaine Avatar

    I think you are right Victoria – those I have read so far have been good and workmanlike and I have enjoyed them but this one was so much better than the others and kept me pinned to my seat until I had finished it.

  6. Victoria Corby Avatar

    This was the first Peter Robinson I read too, I remember being enthralled. They aren’t all as good as this but I still think any of his books are worth pouncing on if you come across them.

  7. Elaine Avatar

    serendipidty again! Let me know what you think

  8. Elaine Avatar

    I did not even know there was a series on TV and then when I did find out and saw the cast thought no way!

  9. Elaine Avatar

    I am now eager to read the rest after this one but shall take my time and not over do it this time as i normally do and then am left bereft

  10. Elaine Avatar

    well start with this one Lisa and let me know what you think!

  11. Elaine Avatar

    Oh yes virginia I have read all of them and think they are excellent and also very witty and amusing

  12. Elaine Avatar

    No need to apologise Ruth. I am here in London today with all my girls!

  13. anne Avatar
    anne

    Our library actually only has ONE P.Robinson book, and it is Dry Season, so am taking it home! Am always thrilled when our little library actually has books you are reviewing!

  14. Liz F Avatar
    Liz F

    Funnily enough this was the first Insp Banks novel that I read, purely because I had just visited a reservoir which was so drought affected that you could see the remains of one of the villages that was flooded when it was made which is right in the area where Banks is purported to be set, albeit in a fictional town.
    I thought it was very good and went on to read as many more as the library had (surprisingly few) but somehow stopped and haven’t got around to reading any more since. I think that I have been put off by the TV series as there is no way that Stephen Tompkinson looks the way I imagined Banks to look and his portrayal was much more miserable than I remember the character being. Somehow now when I think of the Banks books I can’t avoid a mental image of that boiled owl stare and it quite puts me off!

  15. Mary Ronan Drew Avatar

    Just checked and I find I read the first two in the series and gave each 5 stars. Why did I not continue? Well, thanks to your review I’ve requested the third. Can’t wait.

  16. Margaret Powling Avatar
    Margaret Powling

    Yes, I know of this writer but have never read him, so will perhaps now look out for some 2nd hand copies. I’ve not read a detective novel for a while, indeed I even put aside the latest Charles Finch and Elly Griffiths novels for something else with every intention of returning to them … currently deep in historicals of the Restoration period (even ordered Restoration by Rose Tremain, as I want to read her latest, Merivel, but want to read the forerunner, Restoration, first) and have now treated myself to a (2nd hand) copy of a book on Wren, Sir Christopher I mean, not the dickie bird!

  17. Lisa Guidarini Avatar

    Mmm, yum! I’m just now starting to look for such engrossing thrillers – came across Karin Fossum’s name, have you read her? I love Ian Rankin, for one, and preferred settings are villages in Britain. This one, featuring a lost village is exactly my sort of book! Will hit the used bookshops to look for this and also the Vintage Penguins I’ve fallen in lust with. Thanks for the lovely review!

  18. Virginia Avatar
    Virginia

    Have you discovered the Bill Slider detective series by Cynthia Harrod-Eagles? I think they are very well done, and the sense of place – Shepherd’s Bush – feels authentic in the way that d. Leon’s Venice does .( And Bill has, very soon in the series, a happy domestic situation.) I do so agree that Death’s Jest Book was a giant leap for Hill. So now I have to try In a Dry Season, haven’t been overly impressed with Robinson up to now.

  19. Ruth Avatar

    I’ve just read that you are a grandmother again, congratulations Elaine. I do read your blog a lot but seldom leave a comment, sorry!

  20. Elaine Avatar

    Harriet – please let me know what you think!

  21. Elaine Avatar

    HI Jacquie in Rhode Island – so glad you enjoy Random. As I indicated in the post enjoyed the books but this one really was the best so far.
    Off to London today to see my babies!

  22. Elaine Avatar

    Serendipidty Pam! Well yes you must now check it out and please do let me know what you think. I really thought it was excellent

  23. Harriet Avatar
    Harriet

    Well — now you have totally grabbed me. I have immediately ordered this on Amazon and am really looking forward to it — many thanks.

  24. Jacquie Avatar
    Jacquie

    Elaine
    In A Dry Season is the Inspector Banks book that got me hooked on Peter Robinson’s series. I think it is one of the best. I’ve read them all, but must admit that I felt the earlier ones better than the more recent.
    I really enjoy reading your blog from over here in Rhode Island. Your comments on the Queen, Olympics, Wimbledon and Andy winning the U.S. Open are so much fun to read.
    Congratulations on the new granddaughter.
    Jacquie

  25. Pam Travellin Penguin Avatar

    Oh my gosh, this is so weird. Have just been going through my bookshelves wondering what to do with books that have been on the shelves for too long and there are too many and In A Dry Season in definitely in amidst the piles. Well looks like I had better pull that one out and put into my TBR pile asap. Enjoyed the review. Now I have some enthusiasm going here. haha Pam

Leave a Reply to ElaineCancel reply

Discover more from RANDOM JOTTINGS

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading