RANDOM JOTTINGS


A blog about music, sports, theatre and rants





Last year I read Jane Casey's first book, The Missing and was not totally overwhelmed by the ending which I thought rather spoiled the rest of the story.  I said so and then received an email from the author thanking me for my review but saying it had made her 'wince a bit'.  Of course, I was immediately stricken with guilt but this is what reviewing is about and I have to be honest.   Problem is I don't like dissing books in any way as I know full well I am totally incapable of writing a novel and, as a blogger, am very aware that as a critic I am an amateur.  However, I had to tell the truth and after such a promising start I felt really disappointed by the denouement revealing the culprit which I had already guessed as well.

So it was with trepidation that I found myself reading The Burning by the same author and I am going to say straight away, with enormous relief, that I thought it was a terrific read and streets ahead of her first, much better plotted and with more believable characters.

Maeve Kerrigan is an ambitious detective constable and is keen to make her mark.  As a woman in a male environment she has to work twice as hard to prove her worth and also learn to deal with the sexism that is part of her daily routine.  She is involved in the investigation to track down The Burning Man, a brutal Burn serial killer who has beaten four young women to death before burning their bodies.  A fifth body has been found but there are differences in the manner of her death which make Maeve think that this is a separate murder.  She investigates and the more she learns about the victim, Rebecca Haworth from her friends and family, the more she is sure that there are two murderers abroad.  She meets Rebecca's ex-boyfriend Gil Maddick, darkly handsome, brooding and dangerous, her best friend Louise North, cold and self possessed and very jealous of others involved with Rebecca.  It appears that the golden lifestyle enjoyed by Rebecca has been falling apart, a drug habit, broke and now out of a job and all is not as it seems on the surface.

Once started I read right through until the end.   Narrative pacy and strong and I found myself liking Maeve Kerrigan very much and hope that we meet her again in another detective novel.  

I am so pleased that I liked this book and Jane, if you are still reading Random Jottings after last year, then I hope you see this review!

Posted in

6 responses to “The Burning – Jane Casey”

  1. Elaine Simpson-Long Avatar

    Hello Jane so glad you dropped by. Simply delighted to hear that Maeve will appear in your next book – already looking forward to it and so happy that I enjoyed The Burning.

  2. Jane Casey Avatar
    Jane Casey

    I read it and appreciate it! Thanks so much for this review and apologies for making you feel guilty last time, which wasn’t my intention. I think my email was more of an apology than a complaint, and certainly I didn’t mind the critical comments. I’m so pleased that you liked The Burning, though, and I’m glad to say that Maeve will be back next year in my next book.
    The ending of The Missing got a very mixed response – some people liked it while others loathed it. Part of me wishes that everyone thought it was the perfect narrative choice, but I’ve had a truly interesting time discussing it with readers at book clubs and festivals.
    Because of the internet, it’s terrifyingly easy for readers to get into a dialogue with authors, but please don’t let it deter you from speaking your mind. As a writer and a reader, I love to read what other people think about their own reading and I really value thoughtful reviews, even when they’re critical… so carry on, and thanks again!

  3. Elaine Simpson-Long Avatar

    I was so pleased to be able to give this a good review – I hate being unpleasant about a book but when I saw other reviews of the Missing I found that I was not alone so that made me feel better.
    Thank you for those encouraging words LizF – they are much appreciated
    Coffee and a Book Chick – I tend to avoid books I know are not for me so that I can enthuse. Much rather be positive than negative
    So do try this book – I really enjoyed it.

  4. Liz F Avatar
    Liz F

    Another one to look out for – so many books so little time to read them!
    I would have thought that your reviews are more important to a writer as you review from the point of view of someone who reads for pleasure – like most of the potential readers of a detective novel and I don’t think you are ever unfair or critical for the sake of it, unlike some ‘professional’ critics.
    I would imagine that writers, like everyone who puts some part of themselves ‘out there’ have to develop a thicker skin – or just not read the reviews!

  5. Coffee and a Book Chick Avatar

    Good to hear that this worked much more for you — I always feel that punch in the gut as well when I know that I have to honestly review a book that won’t quite make the author happy, but to each her own, and that’s how it can go in this blog review world. But, it makes it that much more tantalizingly delicious when it works, it’s better than before, and we can be blissfully happy that this time, the honest review is wonderful and well-deserved! I look forward to tracking down a copy of her work!

  6. Victoria Avatar
    Victoria

    That’s another one added to my already huge wish list! Thank you for this review because I’m not sure I’d have bothered to read another of Jane Casey’s books after The Missing, I absolutely agree with you about the ending.

Leave a Reply to Elaine Simpson-LongCancel reply

Discover more from RANDOM JOTTINGS

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading