RANDOM JOTTINGS


A blog about music, sports, theatre and rants





When I was painting my bookshelves last week and all my books were in heaps on the floor, I had a bit of a clear out (not a big one, just a few books went) and I realised that I had duplicate copies of many books. I remember my mum always used to ask me why I wanted another copy of a title and difficult to explain why.   So I had a look today at some of my multiple copies and had a think and there are very good reasons why I have them.  Well, I think they are good reasons and I am pretty sure that all book lovers will agree with me.

100_2923-1
The Secret Garden – three copies of  this.  One is a larger illustrated copy I have had for many years, the second was a birthday present and a folio edition and the reason for my picking up the third is that the illustrations are by Shepherd of Winne the Pooh fame and are delightful.

I also have two copies of Frances Hodgson Burnett's A Little Princess though one is, in fact, the slightly earlier version called Sarah Crewe which I found somewhere in a second hand book shop and could not resist.

In fact, Frances Hodgson Burnett is one of the authors where I seem to have a lot of duplicates, Robin and Head of the House of Coombe; I have two old copies of each and one new.   I have two of The Lost Prince and also two copies of The Shuttle.   One is the Persephone edition, but sadly it has been edited so I am very happy that I have an old 1907 edition in brilliant condition which has the full text.

The Making of a Marchioness – again, I have the Persephone edition but also a two volume edition which is how it was first published, The Methods of Lady Walderhurst and the Making of a Marchioness. 

100_2927

I also have a tiny little copy of this book which I found at the back of a cupboard in an old bookshop in Hay on Wye and could not bear to leave it there. So home it came with me to keep the others company.

100_2920-1

100_2922-1

We then come to EM Delafield and at the moment I have five copies of the Diary of a Provincial Lady. I have two copies of the old green Virago publication, found one at a book sale and, again could not bear to leave it behind (once I wear my other one out then I have a replacement), one with a Cath Kidson cover which not sure why I bought really as I think it is a bit twee, and then the Provincial Lady and the Provincial Lady Goes further in an old 1930s edition which I grabbed because of the wonderful illustrations by an artist called G Watt.

I also appear to have three copies of Wind in the Willows, illustrations
by Shepherd so that is a must and, even better, one illustrated by
Arthur Rackham which is superb.

100_2919-1

Two copies of Elizabeth's Adventures in Rugen and I am indebted to Simon of Stuck in a Book who sent me the little Thomas Nelson edition as he could not bear to leave it on a shelf as well.  I was delighted to receive it.

I also have two copies of Christine by Elizabeth Cholmondeley who is Elizabeth von Arnim.  This book is pretty anti-German and as she was married to a German at the time, it did not go down well so she used her maiden name.  I posted about this book here, and a few days later received the most amazing email from a visitor in Australia and if you wanted to know what it said, then read it here.  I was bowled over by its content.

It seems totally illogical to have duplicate copies of books when one is limited for book space as I am and all my shelves are double stacked now as it is and heaven knows where I am going to fit any more, but when I see a book that needs a home I simply cannot bear to leave it behind.

I am pretty sure that all Random Readers will understand……

Posted in , , ,

16 responses to “Duplicates, Triplicates and More”

  1. Claire (Paperback Reader) Avatar

    I try to cull my duplicates but there a number that I hold onto including Angela Carter’s books, Alice in Wonderland and Lolita (for different reasons and some are annotated copies). I justify having both a green Virago and the Cath Kidston designed one because the former has the sequels in it!

  2. Desperate Reader Avatar

    Well at the risk of being outlawed – I just don’t get the duplicate copy thing. I’m stuck for space too and so the idea of using up precious shelf inches with books I already have fills me with horror. I do sometimes buy cheap 2nd hand copies to lend so that it won’t matter if I don’t get them back, or if I find a book so much more lovely than the copy I own I’ll buy it and give the old one away. Sometimes it’s a wrench to leave something very lovely behind even though I already have it, but at least someone else is getting the chance to pick it up.

  3. Liz F Avatar
    Liz F

    I have lots of duplicates, mostly of classic novels and while I did deliberately buy a few of them because the edition was just too beautiful not to, I have to confess that the vast majority came about because I forgot I already had a copy!
    Not sure what my excuse is for not clearing them out, particularly as I have absolutely no more space left for books, but I am sure I will come up with a rationale given time!

  4. Lyn Avatar

    I have lots of duplicates. Rebecca West’s Return of the Soldier, Barbara Pym’s Excellent Women, Cold Comfort Farm, The daughter of Time, Testament of Youth. I also have some cherished ratty paperbacks alongside beautiful Folio Society editions. Several copies of Macbeth because it’s my favourite Shakespeare etc etc. I need all these duplicates, I’m absolutely convinced.

  5. Jeanne Avatar
    Jeanne

    I have a copy of the Persephone edition of The Shuttle by Frances Hodgson Burnett and didn’t realise that it had been edited – should I be disappointed that I don’t have the original?

  6. Virginia Avatar
    Virginia

    My rationale for multiple copies is – if I love it and lend it… and they don’t return it…. So with the books that are my BFFs, I have one-to-read, and at least one and sometimes a second one-to-lend.

  7. Violet Avatar

    ‘…when I see a book that needs a home I simply cannot bear to leave it behind.’ This about sums it up for me too. You have some lovely editions. :)

  8. Elaine Simpson-Long Avatar

    Well I knew you would all be out there! When I stumble across another copy of a well loved book I feel a personal link with it and simply cannot leave it lonely on a shelf. This was what happened with the Making of a Marchioness – I found this tiny little unloved copy at the back of a shelf and knew that it had to come home with me otherwise it would sit there all neglected. When I stumbled across the second Virago edition of Provincial Lady I knew I had to have that as well even though I already had the same copy. I felt, probably wrongly, that nobody else would pick this up and appreciate it. I do wonder sometimes if I have deprived somebody else of finding this and thinking ‘Oh I might try reading this’ but as I could not guarantee it, home it came.

  9. Annabel Avatar

    I understand completely too. I’m a Folio devotee, and have a reading paperback, plus the lovely Folio ones to look at and admire, and old penguins (puffins and pelicans) are like magnets to me too. I found I now have 4 copies/sets of War and Peace – while trying to decide which to read for DGR’s readalong.

  10. Kate Avatar

    Completely understand! Especially considering what lovely editions you have for some of those books.

  11. Susan D Avatar

    Goodness, what is there to understand? As an extreme Dessie (devotee of D E Stevenson)I naturally have multiple editions of many, considering there are US and UK versions, plus various paperback editions.

  12. Debbi Avatar

    Yes. Yes. Yes! As the expression goes, “You are preaching to the choir!”

  13. Sheila Beaumont Avatar
    Sheila Beaumont

    I have two copies of The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, one in a beautiful volume containing all seven Narnia books with original illustrations by Pauline Baynes and hand-colored by the artist herself, the other a hardcover illustrated by Michael Hague. I also had a hardcover set of all the Narnia books illustrated by Baynes, but gave those to my grandsons a couple of years ago.
    Also, I have three hardcovers of The Hobbit, one illustrated by Michael Hague, one illustrated by Tolkien himself, the other an annotated edition. And a set of all the Sherlock Holmes books, plus two enormous annotated editions, with notes by William S. Baring-Gould and Leslie S. Klinger respectively, the latter consisting of three separate volumes.
    I’m sure there are more, but these are the ones I can see on my shelves right now.

  14. Susan in TX Avatar
    Susan in TX

    Totally understand! I think you will find yourself with lots of company. :)

  15. karen Avatar
    karen

    I love this post – one of those “I am not alone” moments! I also bought the Kath Kidston covered Diary of a Provincial Lady as a second copy! I’ve recently had a three-box-clear-out to try and fit all my books on shelves but found it easier to ditch some single copies rather than one of my three beautiful copies of Room With a View! I’m also a sucker for buying old penguin editions of books I’ve already got even though they look as if they will fall apart if read…

  16. Margaret Powling Avatar
    Margaret Powling

    Oh yes, I know only too well about having more than one copy of a book – I even have two copies of Six Cousins Again by Enid Blyton as one has a very good dust wrap and the other is a first edition. I suppose I could put the good dust wrap on the first edition … I also have more than one copy of Mrs Miniver and more than one copy of 84 Charing Cross Road (a falling-apart, to-read-or-lend in paperback and a mint hardback with dustwrap.) But we who love books understand when you see a different copy of a book you already have and love, you reach out and grab it!

Leave a Reply

Discover more from RANDOM JOTTINGS

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading