RANDOM JOTTINGS


A blog about music, sports, theatre and rants





This arrived a few weeks ago from Bloomsbury, complete with a packet of Darjeeling tea and shortbread biscuits.  This was enough to make me feel favourably disposed to this novel and, indeed, I made a cup of tea and retired back to my comfy bed and duvet and started reading this rather delightful book.

Major Pettigrew is a widower, living on his own in the village of Edgecombe St Mary.  One morning shaken  and upset on hearing of his younger brother's death, he is visited by Mrs Ali, who runs the village shop and  she stays to keep him company and comfort him. She, too, is alone her husband having died a couple of years previously. Mrs Ali is a reader and a lover of Kipling and of poetry and this lonely couple begin to find solace and .Major comfort in each other's company and slowly the Major realises that he is falling in love again.

"Mrs Ali was in the living room waiting for him to bring in the tea…..the sun shining through the wobbly glass, made the dust motes shimmer and edged her profile with a light gold brushstroke. She had arrived wrapped in a shawl of deep rose which now lay draped about the shoulders of a wool crepe outfit in a blue as dark and soft as twilight"

The main body of the narrative is the rather tender, lovely story of their growing companionship set against the background of a village with the usual motley collection of eccentrics, gossips and do-gooders and who try, rather embarrassingly hard, to show how multi-cultural they all are.  A farcical Indian themed evening is mounted at the local golf club which ends in embarrassment all round and the members of the club, which include Major Pettigrew's thrusting ambitious son, Roger, all end up behaving rather badly and insulting Mrs Ali.

I very much enjoyed  Helen Simonson's book – the main story of late flowering love between the Major and Mrs Ali is delightful.  The major is chivalrous with an old fashioned courtesy and style of speech which is beautifully captured as is Mrs Ali's warmth of manner and fear of her lonely future.  There are several other stands to the story -Roger Pettigrew, the Major's rather unpleasant son, who is perfectly willing to throw in his lot with a local developer intent on ruining the village with a huge building programme in order to promote his career, Mrs Ali's nephew and his disgrace in making a young woman pregnant and fathering a son, and an attempted murder near the end of the story which brings about a denouement I, personally found melodramatic.   To be honest I was not interested in Mrs Ali's rather tiresome nephew, I just wanted to find out if the Major and Mrs Ali had a happy ending.

 really really loved this book  despite my slight caveat. There was so much in it to enjoy and I found the Major and Mrs Ali so charming and delightful.  I have just passed it to my mother to read (Mother's Day coming up in the UK and I think she will like it) and she has already got stuck in and I look forward to hearing what she thinks.

Please do check out another review of Major Pettigrew on Cornflower Books.  I read this earlier on today and it expressed my feelings about this book perfectly, probably more succinctly than I have done.  I nearly  put a link to it in this post and thought no need to review this as it is all here, but in the end decided to write about the Major and Mrs Ali both of whom are wonderful characters.

PS – Since writing this post, I have had comments from several people in the US, that they found it anti-American which puzzles me slightly.  The portrayal of Sandy, Roger's American girlfriend and an obnoxious, loud and brash property developer, accord with Major Pettigrew's age, army background and temperament and therefore, seem to me, to be spot on.  Once he gets to know Sandy, he begins to like her and appreciate her sense of humour, and the developer is drawn with such broad brush strokes that I cannot see why this would cause offense – he is so over the top that we know he is a caricature and not the real deal.

I would be interested in what any other visitors to Random think of this.

Posted in

16 responses to “Major Pettigrew ‘s Last Stand – Helen Simonson”

  1. Elaine Avatar

    Dear Terrye – you are not the first to make this comment but at the time I just felt that the author was caricaturing an obnoxious kind of American (just as we have obnoxious Brits) and did not have a general anti-American bias. However, since then I have wondered. I do believe that not all Americans are loud obnoxious money grubbing bores just as I hope you believe that not all Brits are fat, overweight, tattooed and get drunk every Saturday night! We all have our own objetionable people.

  2. Terrye Avatar
    Terrye

    I really liked this book when I first started to read it…but I was offended by the overt anti Americanism and did not finish it. Believe it or not, not all Americans are loud, obnoxious money grubbing bores. In fact, I wondered why the author lived in the USA considering her obvious bigotry towards Americans.

  3. jean Avatar
    jean

    Having already started on the second read, I agree entirely with your review.
    A Movie please. Preferably Masterpiece theatre, with Patrick Stewart?

  4. Karen Avatar

    Hi Elaine — Just saw your comment on my blog about this book, and wanted to stop by and second your review. It’s a very charming story, deeply felt. I hope to finish it this weekend, although I’m going to try and resist the shortbread!

  5. Janelle Dvorak Avatar
    Janelle Dvorak

    I loved the cover too!

  6. Margaret Powling Avatar
    Margaret Powling

    Regardless of content, and I think in this case it will match the cover, I love good cover design. My recent reading has been The Fossil Hunter by Shelley (no pun intended, I’m sure) Emling, an American writing about Lyne Regis fossil hunter, Mary Anning. I am thoroughly enjoying this book (although on Amazon it has mixed reviews) and the deligtful cover matches the (to me) excellent content.

  7. Kathryn Avatar

    I recently put this on my to-read list and I’m glad to see here that you enjoyed it. I’ll push it to the top of my list now.

  8. Simon (Savidge Reads) Avatar

    I am really looking forward to reading this one and probably will be over the weekend actually. I got sent the shortbread and some Assam too, so will make it all the more special.

  9. Claire (The Captive Reader) Avatar

    This sounds delightful – I have it on hold at the library and am increasingly anxious for it to come in!

  10. A Bookish Space Avatar

    This sounds wonderful. Thank you for the review.

  11. Carol R. Avatar
    Carol R.

    Elaine — I certainly agree with you. Some covers just beg you to buy the book, but I too have learned that what’s inside may not be of the same quality.

  12. Elaine Simpson-Long Avatar

    Carol – this book is a perfect example of how a cover can attract. As soon as I received this book I wanted to read it purely for this reason. But covers can be deceiving – I recently read a book Ballthazar Jones and the Tower of London Zoo, which was offered to me, purely because I loved the cover. But the story inside was pretty disappointing. In this case, for the most part Major P matched up to the art work.

  13. Cornflower Avatar

    It is lovely, and the main story is just delightful!

  14. Carol R. Avatar
    Carol R.

    Love the cover!

  15. Rebecca (The Reading Diary) Avatar

    It sounds like a delightful book! Thanks for drawing it to my attention!

  16. Verity Avatar

    I love the sound of this book – thank you for such a thoughtful review

Leave a Reply to CornflowerCancel reply

Discover more from RANDOM JOTTINGS

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading