RANDOM JOTTINGS


A blog about music, sports, theatre and rants





I know I keep going on about my back, and I apologise, but when you can barely stand up straight without grimacing and wincing, it looms rather large.  Heaven knows what I would be like if I was really ill.    Anyway, getting better and can actually move about today but the need for comfort reading is still there, and  I found myself pulling down my copy of The Shuttle by Frances Hodgson Burnett.  I have mentioned this before HERE and make no apologies for talking about it again as you may have recently become a reader of Random and I really love this book so much, I would hate anybody to miss it.

The Persephone edition is an edited version (do read all about it in an excellent summary on their website here) as it is a very long book and though I have a copy of this on my shelves, I turned to my full book yesterday and within ten pages was totally immersed for the umpteenth time and could not put it down until it was finished.  Since my last readingI have also read the excellent biography of Frances Hodgson Burnett by Gretchen Gerzina, and this study casts an intriguing light on the author.  I reviewed this on Amazon as it was pre-Random and here is what I said about it at the time:

"Nowadays Francis Hodgson Burnett is known as the author of The Secret Garden and Little Lord Fauntleroy but in her day she was an incredibly successful writer with over 50 adult books to her name. Her books and short stories sold in their millions but it was when she produced Little Lord Fauntleroy that she reached mega-stardom. Just think JK Rowling and Harry Potter and this will give you some idea of how popular this book was at the time. Merchandising is not new, there were Little Lord Fauntleroy cups and plates, picture books etc and thousands of little boys were condemned by their mothers to wearing velvet suits with knickerbockers and to sport long curls. This biography is the first new biography of Frances Hodgson Burnett for over 30 years and makes fascinating reading. Gg She came from a very poor family in England and her widowed mother made a huge leap of faith and emigrated to the US during the Civil War. Not something that really can be viewed as a sensible decision and there the family nearly starved and perished. From her teen years Francis wrote stories and for the rest of her life she supported her family by her writing. Nothing she wrote was ever turned down. This is a fascinating book revealing a complex woman whose attitude and behaviour towards her children may surprise some of us who remember her superb writing of childhood fears and emotions in books such The Little Princess and, of course, Secret Garden. I know it surprised me…. highly recommended"

This time when I finished The Shuttle I felt more strongly than I had before that this is a book, not just about the American/Anglo marriages of the early 20th century, but about the power of love, and I know this is a cliche but in this particular story the narratiave is propelled by family love, that of a sister for her elder sibling who married into the English aristocracy and disappeared from sight.  It is also about the love of the rescuer for England and for the man she meets when she comes to Stoneham Court to rescue her abused sister from her vicious husband.  Betty Vanderpoel meets with an impoverished aristocrat who is totally against these marriages as he feels a man should not sponge off his wife and who will not contemplate such a commercial transaction.  They love each other, a powerful passionate love, but he pulls away, his pride not letting him admit his feelings.  FHB uses the device, a not unoriginal one but it works, of the hero being near death and the power of the prayers of Bettina pull him back from the brink.  He then later appears in response to her silent cries for help when in a dangerous situtaiton and, in his turn, saves her.

In The Making of a Marchioness by FHB we have the same situation – the Marchioness is dying, her husband has been abroad for some months and comes home to find her ill.  She has always loved him, though he has never loved her in the same way, but during the months of their separation and through their letters, he realises that his love for her has grown and when he returns it is he who calls her back from the brink of death.

This afternoon I have read, once more for the umpteenth time, The Head of the House of Combe, another one of FHB's adult books which I would love to see reprinted.  Robin, the neglected and lonely daughter of a society flibbertigibbet, makes friends with a boy in the park when they are both 6 and 8 respectively:

"So they stood and stared at each other and for some strange, strange reason – created perhaps with the creating of Man and still hidden among their deep secrets of the universe – they were drawn to each other – wanted each other  – knew each other"

They are separated as their feelings for each other are not childlike and Donal's mother, in particular, mistrusts the child of a woman with a bad reputation, but they never forget each other and meet up again as young adults.  He, Donal, goes off to fight (it is 1914) and though he disappears, the mysterious kinship and contact that they have never fails even when he is believed dead.

Yes, I know this all sounds rather melodramatic, but somehow it works.  This calling across is not new – don't forget the scene in Jane Eyre when Jane is on the verge of accepting an offer of marriage from St John Rivers and she hears the voice of Rochester calling her name across the moors.  She calls back and later when they are reunited he tells her that he heard her cry.

On recently re-reading Lucy Maud Montgomery and her series of Emily books, the same thing happens.  Emily is accidentally locked in a church and trapped with her is a demented widower always searching for his lost wife.  She is terrified and cries out to Teddy, her friend and kindred spirit to help her, and he does.  He says he 'heard' her, even though he was miles away.

I suppose what I am trying to say, though not very coherently, is that these authors have written with such passion and strength about the power of love.  Charlotte Bronte, LM Montgomery, Frances Hodgson Burnett all yearned for this kind of love for themselves, to no avail.  Charlotte, instead of the Zamorna of her Angrian fantasy, married her father's curate Arthur Bell Nichols and though it proved to be a happy and contented marriage for its brief length, one wonders if  she had lived would she have felt stifled by it all.   FH Burnett was unhappily married as was LM Montgomery, whose journals recnelty read, have revealed how much she suffered from her husband's depressions and the pain of her unsatisfactory elder son.  No wonder they wrote so passionately about love in their novels.

These thoughts were going through my head as I read today and I just wanted to put them down as they are tumbling in my mind, so if this is a slightly disjointed post, then I do apologise.  Sometimes when you have things you want to say and want to say them quickly before you forget, it can get a bit jumbled.

But I am sure you will all understand….

Posted in ,

13 responses to “The Shuttle revisited”

  1. Karen Avatar

    Dear Elaine: I do hope your back is on the mend and that you are better able to get around today. Thank you for calling The Shuttle to everyone’s attention — it sounds terrific. I’m going to be spending a couple of weeks in England very shortly, including a few days in London, and I’ll be making a pilgrimage to the Persephone book shop where I’ll definitely be buying a copy. Karen

  2. Erika Avatar
    Erika

    I have recently had a wonderful reread of lots of FHB but can’t face “That Lass o’ Lowrie’s” Again –just too awful! I was struck by the sudden thought that if she was writing today she would be hauled into court, quick as a wink, for plagiarism of Juliana Horatio Ewing’s “Six to Sixteen”. What–another little orphan girl who lost her parents in an Indian cholera epidemic and then is sent home to England?
    Apart from “The Secret Garden” and her autobiography of her childhood, “The One I knew the Best of All”, I would not recommend her books to anyone–they are an acquired taste, which I have and no way can I be proud of it. (But what a lovely indulgent read they can be!)
    Now I do recommend Mrs. Molesworth as a much better writer and much more sensitive to the private feelings of children. Try “‘Carrots’ just a little boy”–my stomach can ache with sympathy for this poor little scrap, so run over and misunderstood in a large bouncing family.

  3. Verity Avatar

    I haven’t yet read The shuttle, I have the Persephone copy waiting. I did very much enjoy Making of a marchioness though…

  4. Claire Avatar

    I loved The Shuttle (I read it last Christmas) but had no idea that my Persephone copy was an edited one! I am a huge fan of her children’s fiction and have been for a very long time.

  5. Rachel Avatar

    And just completely broke my book ban by bidding on Through One Administration on ebay…but by the sounds of it, it will be worth the guilt!

  6. Rachel Avatar

    Disjointed? Not at all. Another brilliant post that hits the nail right on the head, Elaine. You know already that I love FHB. I have the same Shuttle edition you do thanks to a kind American friend who bought it and shipped it for me from ebay (why are FHB’s so much easier to find in the US I wonder?) and I adore it. I also love Marchioness. I have five adult FHB’s waiting to be read (T Tembarom, That Lass O’Lowries, Louisiana, In Connection with the De Willougby Claim and A Fair Barbarian)- I bought them all after reading the Gretchen Gerzina autobiography and still haven’t got around to reading them. I am now going to make one of them my next read now you have inspired me to get back into FHB. I think she is a terrific writer and was a very complex and interesting woman with a turbulent and conflicted life that she perhaps tried to escape from a little by writing romantic stories about the power of true love. She definitely deserves a wider audience and a revival.

  7. carole Avatar
    carole

    I have The Shuttle stacked up with the other Persephonies, but, as yet, unread. I must go and get it down at once.
    I’m sure it can’t be catching but my back has been agony for the last two days, shall we blame the weather?! I have been rubbing it with arnica massage balm, it smells nice and I think it is a bit soothing. You have my deepest sympathy, it hurts!

  8. Mog Avatar

    Passionate books and passionate post. Very interesting.

  9. Jan Jones Avatar

    “Writing with passion and strength about the power of love”
    Lovely sentence, Elaine. Don’t see how you could put it better, really.
    (Tell your back to improve! Have you tried arnica tablets? Not the cream – the tiny tablets. Magic)

  10. anne Avatar
    anne

    this post wasn’t disjointed at all — lots of passionately stated information, flowing strongly down the page. Thanks for sharing!

  11. Elaine Simpson-Long Avatar

    Well Simon, FHB was a great believer in communication of minds and things mystic so you never know………….T Tembaron might be a good one to start, it has a masculine viewpoint, the others are much more feminine – and I don’t mean that in a sexist way, more practical!
    Nicola, yes Robin/Combe is a bit purple in places I agree but I do love it and find it quite moving

  12. Nicola Slade Avatar

    Oh I really love FHB, specially T Tembarom, and Making of a Marchioness. Robin/Head of the House of Combe is a bit purple prose but a brilliant view of society marriages and the passions roused by WW1. Haven’t read The Shuttle but will do so a.s.a.p. (Currently having a Rosemary Sutcliff orgy, having been on a couple of roman outings, to Silchester, and to Hadrian’s Wall.)

  13. Simon S Avatar

    I have to admit somewhat shamefully that I have never read any Frances Hodgson Burnett and now thanks to another lovely post I have dfound another author I want to read. Though sadly I dont think she will be emailing me like the last one did lol.

Leave a Reply to RachelCancel reply

Discover more from RANDOM JOTTINGS

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading